Author picture

Simon Jimenez

Author of The Vanished Birds

4 Works 1,034 Members 41 Reviews

About the Author

Works by Simon Jimenez

The Vanished Birds (2022) 550 copies, 32 reviews
The Spear Cuts Through Water (2022) 482 copies, 9 reviews
Le pays sans lune (2024) 1 copy

Tagged

(3) 2020 (5) 2021 (4) 2022 (4) 2023 (6) adult (5) ARC (5) audio (3) audiobook (4) BIPOC (3) bookshelf (3) Del Rey (3) ebook (18) epic (5) family (3) fantasy (54) fiction (59) goodreads (5) high fantasy (3) Kindle (10) lgbt (4) LGBTQ (10) LGBTQIA (6) music (4) novel (8) paperback (4) queer (3) read (9) read 2020 (3) read in 2020 (7) science fiction (91) sf (12) sff (14) space (6) space opera (10) space travel (8) time dilation (4) time travel (9) to-read (205) unread (8)

Common Knowledge

Members

Reviews

Excelente lectura, con una prosa y estilo muy agradable y personajes memorables con buen desarrollo. Un final un poco rápido, pero en general esta novela ha sido una muy grata sorpresa.
 
Flagged
daed | 31 other reviews | Oct 6, 2024 |
The Spear Cuts Through Water is a fantasy story: two boys – one an outcast, the other of royal blood – are on the run, escorting the nearly deceased body of a goddess trying to escape her husband, a despotic Emperor, and their monstrous sons, the Three Terrors.

The biggest delight of reading Spear was the wonder Jimenez offers. His worldbuilding and the details of the story offered a fairly consistent stream of the new – like psychic tortoises being used as telecommunication, just to name one thing. Not that Jimenez veers into Weird territory: there is no weirdness or otherness just for the sake of it in this novel.

The result is a story that delivers the unexpected and fantastic regularly, surprising the reader with things they never read about before, but still in a consistent, solid secondary world. For me, reading fantasy is generally about that: invoking awe and escapism through the power of an author’s imagination. Jimenez also describes a fair amount of violence and action. As such, for me this was a book about sets and scenes, and Jimenez excels at it.

There is another layer to this book, a meta one. The story is partially told in the second person (a you that’s a descendant of one of the characters), and some of the story is told to him by his grandmother, and he also sees big parts of the story performed as a dance in some kind of dream theater. That latter mode is the bulk of the novel, and as such Spear mostly reads as a regular 3rd person narrator.

Much is made of this formal structure in other reviews – some even calling the book an experimental triumph. I don’t fully agree.

It’s clear some readers are confused or put off by the formal choices Jimenez made, judging by some Goodreads reviews – mind you, the book still has an excellent rating. Others, like Jake Casella Brookings in the Chicago Review of Books go full on with their praise.

(...)

Full review on Weighing A Pig Doesn't Fatten It
… (more)
 
Flagged
bormgans | 8 other reviews | Sep 9, 2024 |
I absolutely loved [b:The Spear Cuts Through Water|55868456|The Spear Cuts Through Water|Simon Jimenez|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1622813641l/55868456._SY75_.jpg|87081124] and expect it'll be one of my favourite novels of 2024. I can't remember who recommended it to me, but if it was you then many thanks! I was gripped from the very start by the vivid and original narrative style, which has a mythological air, emphatic section headings, and incorporates the thoughts of bystanders:

The country shivered.

It was as though a finger had been run down the spine of the land of the moonless night. From the western mountains this shiver ran, all the way to the eastern shore. Not one of us escaped its chill. It was a collective feeling, come over by all, from the farmers of the Yinn terrace lands to the dock workers in the Divine City. When it reached us, we woke up with a startle, thinking that the world was ending; that our bodies had finished their time on this Earth, and this shiver was the release of our spirit to the Sleeping Sea. The cry of woken babies scored this night of change. The gambling games in the pleasure barges put on pause as the old men and women playing dice now rubbed their arms, warming the small hairs that pricked up from some unknown fright. The fishermen of the Thousand Rivers peered out their boarded windows to perhaps catch sight of the culprit of this bodily premonition, a nightmare spirit perhaps, come to visit them from the water and sated only by the fresh salt tears of the young. But we saw nothing and no one. We had no explanation for the trembling of our body, which lasted for but one soul-freezing moment. [...]

The world had changed. The apes sojourning through the dark forest beyond the torchlight of man held one another as the shiver came and went; their eyes shining in the dark as they understood this portent; the days of great upheaval that lay ahead of them.


This style is positively sumptuous and has a lovely rhythm, which is sustained throughout. The tempo of the plot is also brilliantly done, with events taking place over five tumultuous days and building to a truly epic denouement. The worldbuilding combines fascinatingly horrible magic, clever political economy, and delightful details like the network of psychic tortoises both exploited and used as tools of exploitation. The main protagonists are two young men with very different trauma and a corpse that hasn't stopped moving yet. All three are original and endearing creations. The other characters are likewise memorable and vivid. There is a lot of brutal violence, including cannibalism, but it's in service of the plot rather than being gratuitous. The impact of violence on victims and perpetrators is interrogated cleverly. There is also a sweet and awkward love story to lighten what could have been a grim and dark novel. This ambitious combination of elements is executed with panache. I haven't enjoyed a speculative novel as much since [b:The Actual Star|56304414|The Actual Star|Monica Byrne|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1618279333l/56304414._SX50_.jpg|86058464]. I highly recommend it and plan to track down Jiminez' other novel [b:The Vanished Birds|45422268|The Vanished Birds|Simon Jimenez|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1562699959l/45422268._SY75_.jpg|70173100].
… (more)
 
Flagged
annarchism | 8 other reviews | Aug 4, 2024 |
Set in an incredibly original world, The Spear Cuts through Water is about two men who help a goddess escape captivity. It might sound like a straightforward fantasy quest, but nothing can be further from the truth. The adventures feature a whole lot of deeply weird magic and rituals, including giggling telepathic tortoises, the consummation of divine flesh, monkeys who smoke joints, animals possessed by deities, and more. There is also a puzzling and dreamy framing narrative that seems to involve time travel. To add even more confusion, the book is written in a mix of first, second, and third person, but not divided by chapter or anything. All three grammatical persons can appear within a single sentence, interrupting each other, competing for page time, and it's not immediately obvious if there is a point to it.

Unsurprisingly it takes some effort to grow accustomed to Simon Jimenez's literary experimentation, but it's very much worth it. About one hundred pages in, it becomes impossible to stop reading this book. The flowery writing is lovely and impactful, forcing readers to cling onto every word as Jimenez tells a tale of love, loss, identity, and revolution. While it might be a total fever dream from start to finish, it's one that is breathtakingly beautiful.
… (more)
 
Flagged
tdavidovsky | 8 other reviews | Jul 24, 2024 |

Lists

Awards

You May Also Like

Associated Authors

David G. Stevenson Cover design & illustration
Shayna Small Narrator

Statistics

Works
4
Members
1,034
Popularity
#24,905
Rating
4.0
Reviews
41
ISBNs
21
Languages
2

Charts & Graphs