Geoffrey HomesReviews

There is huge disagreement among film buffs, scholars, the general public, and marketers about what is and isn't film noir. (I'm of the more selective school that says that a film isn't noir just because it's in black-and-white and it's about crime. To me, noir, in a vast oversimplfication, means one thing about the protagonist: he's screwed. If your hero survives or wins the girl and solves the case, then there's a good chance it's not film noir. But, as I said, there's a lot of argument about that.

One thing no one seems to argue about, one film everyone seems to agree is not only film noir but the quintessential film noir is OUT OF THE PAST (1947). Everything people do agree on about noir is in this film, and in it just about perfectly. It's in my top ten films of all time list, and lots of other people's, too.

OUT OF THE PAST is based on the novel BUILD MY GALLOWS HIGH, by Geoffrey Homes (a pseudonym for Daniel Mainwaring). It is as noir as the film, at least. It's plot is roughly the same, but it is a bit more tangled, more intricate, with a pair of antagonists who were combined in the film. The main character, Red Bailey (Jeff in the film), is a former private investigator caught up in the wreckage of a ten-year-old case, with revenge and a femme fatale of the first order dogging his heels. Homes writes poetically, yet with Hemingwayesque strength. The book is no longer than it needs to be, but is rich and evocative. If you've seen the film, the book will strike you as having been perfectly captured in the film, even with the plot adjustments. The same sense of place, of topography, of architecture fills the book. It's a wonderful book, now in my top ten favorite crime novels.

A small-town doctor learns that the population of his community is being replaced by emotionless alien duplicates.

2021 movie #202. 1949. Army paymaster Duke (Mitchum) is chasing a guy through Mexico who stole an army payroll. The guy's fiancee (Greer) is helping him. Duke's captain (Bendix) is after both of them. Good picture with some humor and surprisingly not racist for 1949.

Plants from space are replacing people.

Maybe I would have liked it if I hadn't read the book. I can't tell. During the time when suspense might (or might not) have been building, the adaptation is so close to the book that I couldn't really separate the two. The best thing about the book is the ending, and yet they felt the need to mess it up in both movie versions. In the 70s, they gave it a mindless zombie movie ending. But in this version, they don't even bother to replace it with anything. There's just... no ending. The last 20 minutes of the movie is nothing but flailing gibberish.

Concept: B
Story: C
Characters: C
Dialog: D
Pacing: C
Cinematography: B
Special effects/design: B
Acting: B
Music: C

Enjoyment: C plus

GPA: 2.3/4

309. Then There Were Three, by Geoffrey Homes (read 19 Feb 1947) This is a mystery I read on the train as I went home from college. I don't remember anything about it and made no mention of it in my diary.

Super! The first book I have ever read in which I saw the film (Out of the Past) first! The book & the film are almost identical with the exception of location & a few names in the novel! It was a page turner from the minute I opened it! A complete twist with a hard boiled character & a real seedy cast of dismal beings! I really think that the female character (femme fatale) was the first real "bad girl" of this pulp crime era. She is gritty & takes betrayal to an entirely different level! I couldn't help but to sympathize with the protagonist, being caught in a love triangle, heist, & a web of deceit! Even better was the ending, it was believable & a relief! Written with such wit, bringing out the darkness in every character that crosses the page! Extremely entertaining, it is short & an easy read! I have read it twice this month! I would recommend it!

This book is noir at its best. The cover reads "the quintessence of doomladen romantic noir" which is no exaggeration.

Retired private eye, Red Bailey is happily living in Nevada, fishing and falling in love, and wants to leave his past in the past. Unfortunately he is coerced into performing one last job in order to do so. Fast forward to dead bodies left and right, double crossing femme fatales, dirty cops, and gangsters and you have the essentials of an excellent noir novel.

The excellent movie Out of the Past with Robert Mitchum and Jane Greer was based on this novel, and this is one of those rare cases where both the book and the movie are excellent.

I highly recommend both.

Ex private eye Red bailey thinks his past is finally laid to rest, but then an old friend looks him up and offers him one last job, one that cannot refuse. Written in 1947, this was his final novel before he concentrated solely on screen writing (his films include Invasion of the Body Snatchers) and it is a blinder of a novel. All the noir tropes are here, perfectly presented: dirty cops, gangsters, femme fatales, snappy dialog, double crosses galore and a twisting plot. Mainwaring gloriously entwines the past and present so the setup leaks out slowly, keeping the details hidden even if you 're aware that like a Greek tragedy this doesn't end happily. I highly recommend it for all fans of the genre but I reckon anyone would enjoy it.

great film noir !½

The cover design is of a man carrying a heavy box - a coffin. Spooky.