Glenn Russell's Reviews > The High Window

The High Window by Raymond Chandler
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
23385697
's review

it was amazing



Like all of Raymond Chandler’s novels, The High Window features private detective Philip Marlowe as first-person narrator reporting events unfolding as he attempts to crack a case in sun-soaked Los Angeles. I marvel at his perceptiveness and cleverness. Can anybody surpass Marlowe in his ability to see all the angles, to size people up, to catch all the clues, to ask the right questions, to crack wise at those times cracking wise is the wisest, to put the puzzle together so all the pieces fit in place? Maybe Sam Spade or other top dog dicks but that's about it. Oh, clever Odysseus, who fooled the Cyclopes, who heard the song of the Sirens and lived to tell the tale, Raymond Chandler gave you a rebirth as a private eye.

For anybody unfamiliar with Chandler, here is a snatch of dialogue taking place in Marlowe's office when a member of a very rich family comes to speak with the detective:

He looked me over without haste and without much pleasure. He blew some smoke delicately and spoke through it with a faint sneer.
"You're Marlowe?"
I nodded.
"I'm a little disappointed," he said. "I rather expected something with dirty fingers."
"Come inside," I said, "and you can be witty sitting down."
I held the door for him and he strolled past me flicking cigarette ash on the floor with the middle nail of his free hand. He sat down . . . He leaned back in his chair with the smile of a bored aristocrat.
"All set?" I inquired. "Pulse and respiration normal?" You wouldn't like a cold towel on your head or anything."

Through Marlowe, Chandler introduces us to a host of gangsters, crooks, con-artists, thugs, goons and their dames who take turns planning, threatening and committing violence as if they were flesh-and-blood members of the weasel patrol from Toontown.

Here is another bit of dialogue where Marlowe watches from behind a curtain as a shady nightclub manager speaks to his wife after they find his wife's boyfriend shot in the head:

Silence. Then the sound of a blow. The woman wailed. She was hurt, terribly hurt. Hurt in the depths of her soul. She made it rather good.
"Look, angel," Morny snarled. "Don't feed me the ham. I've been in pictures. I'm a connoisseur of ham. Skip it. You're going to tell me how this was done if I have to drag you around the room by your hair. Now - did you wipe off the gun?"

Philip Marlowe is not only an incredibly super-sharp observer, but he is also an intelligent, well-educated, highly ethical man. Two cases in point: when the name Heathcliff is mentioned, he knows the character is from Wuthering Heights and when someone shows him entries in a diary, he alludes to the Diary of Samuel Pepys.

This contrast between the crime and social grime of 1940s Los Angeles and the presence of Philip Marlow gives Chandler's work real abiding depth.

There are hundreds of authors, some very good, who have written detective fiction or crime fiction but what sets Raymond Chandler apart is the polished literary language matching any American author, including the likes of F. Scott Fitzgerald, Ernest Hemingway, William Falkner.

This is the prime reason I have included the above quotes and the reason I will end this review with another sparkling vintage Chandler quote, this one where Marlowe describes the woman he sees when being led by a tall, dark, olive skinned crook to the back yard of a suburban LA mansion:

"A long-limbed languorous type of showgirl blond lay at her ease in one of the chairs, with her feet raised on a padded rest and a tall misted glass at her elbow, near a silver ice bucket and a Scotch bottle. She looked at us lazily as we came over the grass. From thirty feet away she looked like a lot of class. From ten feet away she looked like something made up to be seen from thirty feet away. Her mouth was too wide, her eyes were too blue, her makeup was too vivid, the thin arch of her eyebrows was almost fantastic in its curve and spread, and the mascara was so thick on her eyelashes that they looked like miniature iron railings."

173 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The High Window.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
November 28, 2013 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-46 of 46 (46 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Dolors (last edited Feb 07, 2015 07:23AM) (new)

Dolors I recently watched the latest film by Iñarritu, "Birdman", which is framed in current Broadway. The protagonist (a brilliant Michael Keaton) is trying to pull together a bunch of histrionic actors and actresses to play an adaptation of Raymond Chandler's story "What We Talk About When We Talk About Love" and prove his value as a true actor and director. I loved the script of the film and located a few ingenious remarks and in-depth references to other literary works in the passages by Chandler that you quoted. Certainly, an author to add to my TBR pile. Excellent review, Glenn.


Henry Avila Wonderful review, Glenn. I too love Chandler but read only two of his books. But will read more in the future.His are the best mystery novels, in fact , their great literature.


message 3: by Glenn (last edited Feb 07, 2015 09:28AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Glenn Russell Dolors wrote: "I recently watched the latest film by Iñarritu, "Birdman", which is framed in current Broadway. The protagonist (a brilliant Michael Keaton) is trying to pull together a bunch of histrionic actors ..."

Thanks so much, Dolors. That film and script sounds fascinating. Perhaps "What We Talk About When We Talk About Love" could have some Chandler references but I suspect it might have a more direct connection to that other great American litearary Raymond C -- Raymond Carver.


Glenn Russell Henry wrote: "Wonderful review, Glenn. I too love Chandler but read only two of his books. But will read more in the future.His are the best mystery novels, in fact , their great literature."

Thanks, Henry. Yes, I love Chandler and Marlow. At the moment I am listening to the audiobook of 'The Little Sister' -- one of my favorite Chandler. The language is amazing.


message 5: by Dolors (new)

Dolors Yes, you are right Glenn, I didn't check the name and my unreliable memory tricked me. The cited story included a crime and acerboc dialogues though, so I might have to include both authors!


Glenn Russell Dolors wrote: "Yes, you are right Glenn, I didn't check the name and my unreliable memory tricked me. The cited story included a crime and acerboc dialogues though, so I might have to include both authors!"

And you might really like a remarkable Robert Altman film based on Carver's stoires --- Short Cuts. One of my all-time favorite films.


message 7: by Glenn (last edited Feb 07, 2015 04:49PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Glenn Russell Edward wrote: "Excellent and thanks again for that Glenn. Chandler's my favorite noirist. Can you picture him trying to outwit Seneca?"

Ha! Those two would make quite a pair, both so so sharp.


message 8: by Martin (new)

Martin Zook "Can anybody surpass Marlowe in his ability to see all the angles, to size people up, to catch all the clues, to ask the right questions, to crack wise at those times cracking wise is the wisest, to put the puzzle together so all the pieces fit in place?"

Well, come to think of it, yes. C. Auguste Dupin.


Glenn Russell Martin wrote: ""Can anybody surpass Marlowe in his ability to see all the angles, to size people up, to catch all the clues, to ask the right questions, to crack wise at those times cracking wise is the wisest, t..."

Ha! Could you kindly be more specific on your judgement here?


message 10: by Martin (new)

Martin Zook I'm afraid that Marlowe and the lot, no disrespect intended, must tip their feforas to Edgar Allan Poe's C. Auguste Dupin, for without him, there would be no them.

Check out The Mystery of Marie Roget, The Gold-Bug, and The Purloined Letter, if you're not pulling my leg.

Really? You haven't read the father of fictional detectives? I thought you've read everything.


Glenn Russell Thanks for being back with me, Martin. Yes, hail to EAP, the father of detective fiction! And, yes, I read those Poe tales, but many, many years ago. Actually, I thought you might have included a quote similar to this one from Wikipedia: “He employs what he terms "ratiocination". Dupin's method is to identify with the criminal and put himself in his mind. By knowing everything that the criminal knows, he can solve any crime.” Thus, with such a statement, by definition Dupin cannot be surpassed or, perhaps, even equaled.

But, with the need to be very physical and take many a punch and a beating frequently required in the criminal world of LA whilst solving a case, in such a world, I’d still take Marlowe.

Like many of my Goodreads friends, although I’ve read a lot, I make no claims of having read everything.


message 12: by Martin (new)

Martin Zook I almost did allude to ratiocination, but it sounded as if you were unfamiliar with the patriarch of fictional detectives. If it's fisticuffs and wisecracks you're partial to, then I'll concede the point. But when it comes to detecting the truth, Dupin's the man, for the one-eyed reader anyway.


Glenn Russell The one-eyed reader displays great wisdom.

One reason I compared Marlowe to Odysseus – many times our world requires us to display physical prowess,an ability to string the bow, so to speak.


message 14: by Donna (new)

Donna As always, wonderful review Glenn.


Glenn Russell Donna wrote: "As always, wonderful review Glenn."

Thanks so much, Donna. I really enjoyed writing this review of one of Chandler's novels. The High Window, The Big Sleep and The Little Sister are my very favorites.


message 16: by Martin (new)

Martin Zook Ha, Glenn. I failed to factor the Greeks into the equation. Of course the direct equivalent to stringing the bow in America is sighting the handgun, especially the snub-nosed .38 in Marlow's time. It's interesting though how detectives have through the ages been more dependent on their skills of detection than their shooting skills, or ability to take a punch. I wonder how many dicks regularly are armed?


message 17: by Glenn (last edited Feb 08, 2015 06:01AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Glenn Russell Martin wrote: "Ha, Glenn. I failed to factor the Greeks into the equation. Of course the direct equivalent to stringing the bow in America is sighting the handgun, especially the snub-nosed .38 in Marlow's time. ..."

Hey, Martin. Thanks for your post here. Although I am far from one of those readers who has read many, many detective novels, when it comes to packing heat, it is only an occasional thing with most dicks.

On the topic, I really am continually amazed at the perceptiveness of dicks like Marlowe and Spade and the Continental Op, not to mention those 19th century supersleuths, and in our current day, Jo Nesbo's Harry Hole. Perhaps, because my way of looking at the world is so completely opposite to theirs. Matter of fact, I would undoubtedly make the world's worst detective.


message 18: by Martin (new)

Martin Zook Likewise, Glenn. I have come to detective stories and noir late in life, but it's the perceptions that at times have me giggling because of what I miss but seems so obvious after all is revealed.

I'm also a sucker for magic. Even when I know the trick, I can't see it when performed by a half competent illusionist.

I mention the gun as an extension of the bow in a Mcluhanesque twist. I know you meant it as a metaphor for the need to engage in the rough and tumble.

But, the detective in our family disdains the 9 mm in favor of the .38 and looks down on guns, and he's a cop. The private dicks I've known, not many admittedly, don't regularly pack heat.

Still, I think the old school fictional dicks sometimes packed. That's made pretty clear in The Maltese Falcon.


Glenn Russell Martin wrote: "Likewise, Glenn. I have come to detective stories and noir late in life, but it's the perceptions that at times have me giggling because of what I miss but seems so obvious after all is revealed.

..."


Thanks. Great you have some first-hand experience with some real live detectives. I myself have never been even close to knowing a detective. In the spirit of humor, I can just imagine in my mind's eye my sons - a mathematician and an economist -- flashing a buzzer and drilling a thug.


message 20: by Martin (new)

Martin Zook The vast majority of private detective work, assuming I am correctly informed, involves documenting the activities of a cheating spouse. Hardly requires a firearm.

The image of a mathematician/economist executing his job with a firearm seems what Aristotle would have called an improbable improbability. Speaking of probability, I'm sure your son not only could deduce, or induce, some probability that not only would do the job more cleanly, but would entertain a bigger "wow" factor.


Glenn Russell Martin wrote: "The vast majority of private detective work, assuming I am correctly informed, involves documenting the activities of a cheating spouse. Hardly requires a firearm.

The image of a mathematician/eco..."


Agreed! And thanks for the Aristotle reference.


message 22: by Martin (new)

Martin Zook He's the only Greek philosopher who spoke to me. When I was a city hall reporter in Oklahoma City, back in the day, I worked on an underdog paper in that competitive market.

I knew the paper was on its last legs. I gave it 6 mos and that was on the money. So I needed to distinguish my copy from the rest of the media.

Aristotle's poetics, emphasizing the action, character, and thought (what is possible looking forward given the action and characters) gave me the edge I needed. His thoughts on probability honed the equation.

The best example was the budget story. The city manager proposed cutting fire and police from the budget under constraints of reduced federal funding. We broke that story even though I wasn't yet officially on the payroll.

After much karaoke, of course the police and fire were restored. At the dog and pony show to announce the restoration, reporters were hanging out of the rafters. I'd already written my story before the announcement and was just standing in the doorway to see if I'd have to rewrite it.

Not necessary. Every story to come out of that meeting said the fire and police had been restored. Our story said the water rates for the good citizens of OKC were going up, and their trash pickups were being cut to once a week to fund the restoration of fire and police.

Our followup story revealed that the whole show, orchestrated by the city manager, was a misdirection (speaking of magic) to protect federal block grants that the administration wanted used to fund parks, which normally would have been cut. The strategy was so effective that parks weren't mentioned once during the entire hearing process.

And what never ceases to amaze me is how effective such an approach is, especially in the digital age, which emphasizes the forward looking.

But, as the Greeks knew, backing into the future makes us most comfortable.


Glenn Russell Martin wrote: "He's the only Greek philosopher who spoke to me. When I was a city hall reporter in Oklahoma City, back in the day, I worked on an underdog paper in that competitive market.

I knew the paper was o..."


Great story. Thanks.

Perhaps you are familiar with hard-boiled crime writer Jim Thompson. I enjoyed his book, Bad Boy, a recounting of his wild times growing up in Oklahoma. If I recall correctly, at some point young Jim worked for a newspaper.


message 24: by Glenn (last edited Feb 08, 2015 10:12AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Glenn Russell Ben wrote: "I really enjoyed your review! But may I nominate Chesterton's Father Brown as a match for any sleuth in respect of sheer cleverness?"

Yes, you certainly can!

So glad my review has prompted serious readers on Goodreads to speak up on behalf of their choice for top detective.

I haven’t read all that many detective novels, but I’ve read enough to add four of my own:

Dashall Hammett’s Nick Charles and Continental Op
Jo Nesbø’s Harry Hole
Henning Mankell's Kurt Wallander

May the list grow!


message 25: by Martin (new)

Martin Zook The detective genre has morphed, or at the least developed an offshoot. James Ellroy's work is a case in point. His detectives are all cops, or at least the ones I've read.

They retain a high degree of that cowboy quality, while remaining in the system, in contrast to the private dicks such as Marlowe and Spade.


message 26: by Dillwynia (new) - added it

Dillwynia Peter I recently read The Little Sister & loved - as with other Chandlers. I honestly that I had read them all, so it is a nice surprise to encounter another. On to the to-read list it goes.


Glenn Russell Dillwynia wrote: "I recently read The Little Sister & loved - as with other Chandlers. I honestly that I had read them all, so it is a nice surprise to encounter another. On to the to-read list it goes."

Thanks, D. I read The Little Sister a couple of times 20 years ago and, as per post #4 above, I am listening to the audiobook now. But no matter how many times I read a Chandler book, Marlowe is still many steps ahead of me.


message 28: by Dillwynia (new) - added it

Dillwynia Peter As to your review - I love Marlowe's wit. It is obvious that he is so much better educated than those around him.

Makes me think of Chandler as a person. I know he went thru the English public school system. Did he feel the same way living in the West Coast?? I know those educated English writers & actors working in Hollywood did (as did the New York emigres).

The other thing apparent: most of the men in town are returned servicemen, so they are all competent with a gun. Unlike now when the majority of the population are inexperienced (even if they have a gun in the bedroom bureau).


message 29: by Glenn (last edited Feb 10, 2015 04:32PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Glenn Russell Thanks so much for your post here, D.

I don't know that much about Raymond Chandler other than he was a well-educated Englishman (somewhere on the net I listened to an interview where he was speaking about detective fiction).

Philip Marlowe reflects on how he was raised in a small town (in The Little Sister) and how an injury playing in a game ended his college football career at UCLA (in The Long Goodbye, if I recall correctly).

Someone on a website notes how Marlowe grew up in the small town of Santa Rosa.

And I did read somewhere that one reason LA during the time of Marlowe was so violent was the war veterans returned with all their wartime experience and ability to use guns. --- I don't know how accurate this statement is, but I recall reading.


Glenn Russell Edward wrote: "I read somewhere that Chandler was a fired oil company executive, who only started writing after that."

That's right, Edward. Amazing as it might appear, Chandler only started writing after his oil company career, in his late 40s/ early 50s, if I recall correctly.


message 31: by Dillwynia (new) - added it

Dillwynia Peter It gives me hope with my fiction writing career. I have plots, but I fill my spare time with other chores - such as work, which I enjoy. Only nutters & botanists go on holidays to collect more plants to work on when they get back to the office.


Glenn Russell Dillwynia wrote: "It gives me hope with my fiction writing career. I have plots, but I fill my spare time with other chores - such as work, which I enjoy. Only nutters & botanists go on holidays to collect more plan..."

Her name escapes me, but an English author of fine literary fiction started writing in her late 60s after she retired from her job at the civil service office.


message 33: by Dillwynia (new) - added it

Dillwynia Peter Mrs Phyllida James maybe??


message 34: by Glenn (last edited Feb 10, 2015 11:14PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Glenn Russell Dillwynia wrote: "Mrs Phyllida James maybe??"

Are you alluding to P.D. James? I ask since although P.D. James published her first novel when she was 42, she didn't become a full-time writer until in her 60s.

And, in the world of philosophy, Bertrand Russell and Mortimer Adler (to name just 2) were authors who wrote well into their 90s.

Anyway, all this to say, it is never too late to create quality writing.


message 35: by Dillwynia (new) - added it

Dillwynia Peter Bertrand Russell is a distant relative, so I have a lot to work towards.

My problem is I write great science that is interesting; my layman science writing is really accessible & interesting; my conversation is often on par with Stephen Fry, so witty & entertaining (why you should write is a common cry); my fiction writing sadly turns to stodge. Why Fates!! Why??

It isn't too late, so those story ideas could be massaged for those retirement years.


Glenn Russell Dillwynia wrote: "Bertrand Russell is a distant relative, so I have a lot to work towards.

My problem is I write great science that is interesting; my layman science writing is really accessible & interesting; my c..."


Fascinating. Thanks for sharing. And all the best wishes in all your writing.

Although I am not related to Russell, at least I have an interest in philosophy and share his name!


William I just discovered that the audio book is narrated by Elliot Gould! Wow, shades of The Long Goodbye again!


Glenn Russell William wrote: "I just discovered that the audio book is narrated by Elliot Gould! Wow, shades of The Long Goodbye again!"

Yes, I recall listening to a number of Chandler novels narrated by Elliot, including The Big Sleep. He does a good job with all the voices.


William Ah yes, Gould. He had me with the first olive.

M.A.S.H.

Been addicted ever since.


message 40: by Britton (new) - added it

Britton I’m often surprised how many ‘literary’ authors like Chandler (Chabon, Lethem, etc) as well as how many people like him in general, rather it be PKD or Saul Bellow.


Glenn Russell Britton wrote: "I’m often surprised how many ‘literary’ authors like Chandler (Chabon, Lethem, etc) as well as how many people like him in general, rather it be PKD or Saul Bellow."

Thanks for reading and commenting, Britton. Yes, it is surprising how pervasive the influence of Raymond Chandler.


message 42: by Gary (new) - rated it 4 stars

Gary Sites Fantastic review!


Glenn Russell Gary wrote: "Fantastic review!"

Hey, Gary. Thanks, man! And thanks for asking to be my Goodreads friend. Say, if you like crime fiction, you might want to check out my Westlake writing as Richard Stark reviews - the 24 Parker novels. I reviewed them all!


message 44: by Gary (new) - rated it 4 stars

Gary Sites Yes, Sir, I will definitely check them out!


message 45: by Robin (new)

Robin Dolors wrote: "I recently watched the latest film by Iñarritu, "Birdman", which is framed in current Broadway. The protagonist (a brilliant Michael Keaton) is trying to pull together a bunch of histrionic actors ..."


Wow, I didn't know about the Chandler reference. Thank you for sharing that. I loved "Birdman" too. Fabulous review, Glenn. I always learn something valuable from your insights.


Glenn Russell Fabulous review, Glenn. I always learn something valuable from your insights. ----------- That's so wonderful to hear, Robin. I LOVE sharing with friends here on Goodreads and plan to continue.


back to top