Destiny Sidwell's Reviews > If Only I Had Told Her

Honestly, I just finished it like 30 seconds ago and same…

Same.

I started it, got like 50 pages in and stopped because I wasn’t feeling it…seeing these comments I don’t feel so bad.

Same. It fell very flat for me…

sorry des!! im still excited to start ihhbwm <3

this is not what i wanted to hear 😫

OH MY GOD

STOP NO

OMGGGGF

OH MY GODD NOOO 😭

literally just was gonna start reading it rn…

noooo i had such high hopes for this book!! 😭

Same 😭

i love your videos and literally same babe. this book was so overhyped…slow…boring….uneventful….and disappointing. i should’ve known a decent sequel is a rare find. ⭐️⭐️/5 two stars.

Tbh same.

i dnfed it, i just couldn’t do it

what did you rate it?

yeah

Same I DNFed at like 50%

ngl I literally cried through the whole thing and loved most of it but the book almost feels incomplete. like I didn’t realize the end was the end until I saw the acknowledgments page

same.. it's not what i expected in any way

Same felt unnecessary

same - i feel like there wasn’t enough emotion in both books to rlly connect me to the characters !!

Awwwww that makes me sad

I thought it was fine. The “Jack” chapters were definitely the best as we really didn’t get to know him in the first book. I wanted more though.

i agree. the first book just holds a special place in my heart

I agree…

disappointed with finny’s pov

I’m disappointed with the book as a whole. I wanted more from Finny, I didn’t really care for Jack’s point of view as much. The ending is what really did it for me. I wanted to love it and the first couple chapters I did but it fell flat and got so boring for me.

Pffft— I was wondering if I should read this book. But now, seeing all these comments, I don’t want to waste my money 😭. I’m sure the authors writing is good! But it just doesn’t sound like I would enjoy it 😭🫶🏻

This reminds me of It Stars With Us basically a book I didn't need it and felt annoyed that I wasted my time with it

i was kinda disappointed too this book i feel like dragged on to long and finnys pov wasn’t as heat felt as i had hoped

Does anyone have a great friendship books

Is this a retelling of the events in the first book?

No it’s from after what happened in the first book but finny’s point of view begins near the end of the first book

like, was it still good? i'm just starting ihhbwm, sooo...

Anyone else think that jack was gonna end up with autumn and then the end just casually ends up with Sylvie smh I was disappointed.

I see how it might be disappointing for people.. but honestly I loved getting a second book and hearing from Finn’s pov. I became very attached to the first book and their story so maybe that is why I loved this one as well.
I recommend going in with the expectations of just enjoying hearing more from the characters and being back in their world!

I don’t think I can out myself through that again…but I probably will🙃

Same. Could have left it at the first book

Same. Same.

I definitely was. It wasn't a book that needed a sequel to begin with

Same.

agreed. this book only made me hate autumn but ihhbwm used to be one of my favorite books so this is saying ALOT

Me too.

so real

It was just ok for me. The first was so much better.

I agree. I was disappointed as well. The first one literally broke my heart and I couldn’t pick up another book for days. My heart still hurts when I look at the cover. This one was ok but did not evoke the same feelings.

I was so close to not finishing it. I was so very disappointed 😢

Same