In Paper Mario and Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door, Honey Syrups restore 5 FP. In Paper Mario, a Monty Mole will sometimes drop a Honey Syrup. Honey Syrups also have stronger versions such as Maple Syrup and Royal Syrup. It is replaced in Super Paper Mario by the Honey Jar. Cooking just a Honey Jar will give you a Fresh Juice.
| Items Needed | Outcome | Game |
|---|---|---|
| Honey Syrup and Mushroom | Honey Shroom | PM/TTYD |
| Life Shroom and Honey Syrup | Honey Super | PM/TTYD |
| Ultra Shroom and Honey Syrup | Honey Ultra | PM/TTYD |
| Cake Mix and Honey Syrup | Honey Candy | PM/TTYD |
| Super Shroom and Honey Syrup | Honey Super | PM/TTYD |
| Coconut and Honey Syrup | Tasty Tonic | PM |
| Lime and Honey Syrup | Tasty Tonic | PM |
| Lemon and Honey Syrup | Tasty Tonic | PM |
| Apple and Honey Syrup | Tasty Tonic | PM |
| Blue Berry and Honey Syrup | Tasty Tonic | PM |
| Red Berry and Honey Syrup | Tasty Tonic | PM |
| Maple Syrup and Honey Syrup | Fresh Juice or Super Soda | PM/TTYD |
| Yellow Berry and Honey Syrup | Tasty Tonic | TTYD |
| Special Shake and Honey Syrup | Melon | TTYD |
| Jammin Jelly and Honey Syrup | Melon | TTYD |
| Volt Shroom and Honey Syrup | Honey Super | TTYD |
| Turtley Leaf and Honey Syrup | Fresh Juice | TTYD |
| Gradual Syrup and Honey Syrup | Fresh Juice | TTYD |
| Peachy Peach and Honey Syrup | Fresh Juice | TTYD |
| Point Swap and Honey Syrup | Mushroom | TTYD |
| Ice Storm and Honey Syrup | Icicle Pop | TTYD |
| Keel Mango and Honey Syrup | Fruit Parfait | TTYD |
| Hot Sauce and Honey Syrup | Tasty Tonic | TTYD |