I think it's time to start considering the name for the current arc.
Some suggestions:
-Shintei Campaign Arc
-Battle at Eitei Plains Arc
-Han Invasion Arc
If you have some other ideas post it here.
@ErebusF @Gundamexia4502 @Marcusx8 @PlatinumFist(7
2,195
pages
ALL POSTS
All posts by Cichy77
0
Since there's no clear proof they were generals at any point in their life I don't think it's right to put it in the articles based only on speculation.
1
I don't see it as a big issue, but if you want to implement it I'm fine with that, since it could help to organize this section better.
1
Conquest of Han Arc seem to be the most preferable here, so I guess we should go for it.
0
He mentions that he can fight with a glaive in chapter 613.
1
Yeah, Three Pillars Arc seem the most fiting at this point.
2
For now it's best to wait few more weeks and see if there's a continuation between whatever happens now and 230 B.C. It's possible we will have two separate arcs focused on Han one after the other. If thats the case then naming just one Conquest of Han Arc could be a bit misleading.
1
If we are doing that whole master / expert / competent thing we should at least be consistant about it. Personally I'm fine with either choice.
(Edited by Cichy77)
1
It's not a new rank. They are still regular generals, just with bigger personal armies. Kinda like Kanki and Ousen before 6GG system was revived.
In chapter 797 it's mentioned that quote "Ousen Army had been reduced to virtually nothing more then their headquarters". Which suggests that all the minor commanders from Akou / Makou / Denrimi armies are either dead or captured.
In that case should we mark them as (assumed †) even if we haven't seen them die onscreen?
@ErebusF @Gundamexia4502 @PlatinumFist(7 @Dr. Dementor @Marcusx8
The correct romanization of her name is You Tan Wa, not Yo Tan Wa. In hiragana thats ようたんわ. It seem like the early translations were using incorrect form and it sticked, but the newer sensescans chapters are translating it as You Tan Wa for some time.
Since correcting it would require some work should we leave it or change it?
@ErebusF @Gundamexia4502 @PlatinumFist(7 @Dr. Dementor @Marcusx8
(Edited by Cichy77)
0
I feel like naming it "Northern Zhao Invasion" might lead to some confusion, since there are already two invasions of northern Zhao and we still may get another one in the future. I guess if we really want the title related to north then "Great Northern War" sounds best.
Battle of Hango / Hango Campaign is probably the safest choice.
1
Hi Shin Unit is the name we were given in all translations so far and Hara made sure to explain the name hasn't change.
So far the manga makes clear distinction between the two.
軍 - army (used for Gaku Ka, Gyouku Hou after promotion to generals)
隊 - unit, company, corps (used for Hi Shin all the time)
Even if you think "Hi Shin Unit" is not the right translation, it definitely shouldn't be "Hi Shin Army" since the author separates the two terms. HSU is simply an exception to the rule. You might not like it, but this is how Hara-sensei wishes to be so we should respect his choice.
(Edited by Cichy77)
0
Btw. in the recent chapter 770 it seem like Hara is saying that the name will remain "Hi Shin Unit" regardless of how big their number will get. Kinda proves my point that the separation of the two is unnecessary.
I took a look at HSU article and honestly I think it's a mess. I have few ideas on how we can improve it so it will be a bit more coherent.
1.Hi Shin Unit and Hi Shin Army
I don't see a reason why those are two seperate articles. Hara continues to refer to it as "Hi Shin Unit" and even if that was not the case it's still the same military organization as before. And both articles share a lot of the same information so it's just repeating the same stuff.
2. Story sections
I noticed there is a separate article for the story, but there are also sections for the story within main HSU/HSA articles. Whats the point in keeping both? We either delete story article or the sections within main articles so it wouldn't double.
3. Units and Elite Troops Section
Honestly I think it would be best to completely delete this section and replace it with your standard gallery for units like with other armies. Not only this format of presenting units is the most messy and unreadable thing on this wiki, but also completely different to how other armies articles show it.
If you disagree or have other suggestions please share it here.
1
Thats fine with me.
1
Adjutant - 副官
Lieutenant - 副長
Vice / Deputy General - 副将
Captain is just a name for a leader of an unit, you can be a captain and have whatever rank.
1
Either "Philosophical study Arc" or "Nature Of Humanity Arc" would probably be my pick.
1
It sounds good, but the arc might extend after the reconnaissance and continue Kan Pishi's story in Kanyou. If that is the case then a better name might be something related to him like "Kan Pishi Scheme Arc" or something similar.