"How could this have happened?"
"What do you have to say"
"You guys ate all the cake without me?"
we deserved a little treat."
"You were the only one home."
"Tilly, you believe me, right?
"the only one home, and..."
"Please! I'm beggin' ya!"
a sacred oath of loyalty."
the most extreme situations."
"But I swear on sibling-hood,
Really, Cricket? Is there anything you're forgetting to say, like what were you really doing inside the house supposedly resting your hurt arm?
"And if he invokes sibling code,
then he is telling the truth."
"Oh, I could get into that."
"But the evidence is pretty incriminating."
"Cricket is my baby brother."
"I will defend him in life,
"You have an hour while I make a new cake."
"Court is now in session!"
"Lady and gentleman of the jury."
"But you know what ingredient is NOT
"And that is what we have
"Let us review the timeline."
"Mama finished making the cake after breakfast."
"The four of us left to do chores at 9:00 a.m., leaving Cricket and his injured arm home alone."
"At 11:20 a.m., we arrived back at the house, at which point..."
"We were all in the garden,
and I checked on it through the window."
"That means I'm innocent, right?"
"It means Mama must prove
you ate the cake some time
"There's a huge mess in the kitchen,
and I know exactly how it got there..."
"You make an interesting point, Mama."
"You said you saw the cake
"The mess inside the house
could have been caused before 11:00
"but we've got all the evidence we need, right here."
"So, what do you say we call it?"
"I can't believe you, Cricket!
"I don't know how the icing
"I was tellin' the truth before,
"And you've broken my trust."
for somethin' I didn't do,
and I even missed my call
"You had a video call planned with Gabriella?"
"Why didn't you mention it before?"
"Well, 'cause it never happened."
"I was just about to call her
when y'all got back from doin' chores."
"Stop what you're doing!!"
"That Cricket is very much responsible
for all the evidence Mama presented."
"What are you doing...?!"
Cricket had a video call planned
with his Big City girlfrield.
"Seen here, in this drawing I found hidden in Cricket's room."
"What's your point, Tilly?!"
"Not as a way to be alone
incredibly nervous whenever he speaks with Gabriella."
"When nervous, Cricket is prone to singing and dancing with unbridled aggression,
in order to soothe himself."
"OOOOOH, I JUST GOTTA BE FREE!"
So it turns out the kitchen disaster was Cricket's fault.
"Cricket could have worked up quite a sweat."
"And for a creative boy, anything could be a towel."
Gramma: "I hand-sewed those in 1950!"
So Cricket was the one behind the sweaty cushion as well.
"Cricket likes to climb up high,
to make himself feel real tall and powerful."
So that's how the strawberry icing got on Cricket's arm.
"That's exactly what happened!"
"That's all speculation!"
"You have no proof that Cricket
in the 20 minutes after!"
"May I present to the court,
And now, let's take a look at what REALLY happened while Cricket was alone...
"You always rehearse before makin' a phone call?"
Was this really why he didn't tell his family what he was doing earlier?
"Cricket's rehearsal video is
an embarrassing 32 minutes long."
"Like, is cereal a soup?"
"CRICKET!!!"
(That was the part Cricket was called downstairs.)
"My client's mouth was full of love."
"Do the innocence wave with me, Ma!"
"Thank you for trusting Sibling Code."
"And for knowing me better than anyone else."
"I love you, baby brother."
for something you didn't do!"
"But if Cricket didn't eat the cake..."
something we're missing."
"And now for a poem, "From the Fires of my Heart"."
"I know who took the cake!"