Comet vintages

Comet vintages are years during which an astronomical event, involving generally a "Great Comet", occurs prior to harvest. Throughout the history of wine, winemakers have attributed successful vintages and ideal weather conditions to the unexplained effects caused by the comets.^[1] Some of the most heralded vintages in the last couple of centuries—such as the 1811, 1826, 1839, 1845, 1852, 1858, 1861, 1985, and 1989 vintages—have coincided with a notable appearance of a comet.^[2] There is no scientific basis for any effect of comets on viticulture, but the term nevertheless remains in use.

The term "comet wine" is sometimes used in the wine world to describe a wine of exceptional quality in reference to the high reputation that comet vintages have.^[3] The 1811 comet vintage, coinciding with the appearance of the Great Comet of 1811, is perhaps the most famous. The 1811 Château d'Yquem has exhibited what wine experts like Robert Parker have described as exceptional longevity with Parker scoring the wine a perfect 100 points when tasted in 1996. The 1811 vintage of Veuve Clicquot is theorized to have been the first truly "modern" Champagne due to the advancements in the méthode champenoise which Veuve Clicquot pioneered through the technique of remuage.^[2]^[4]

Effects of the comets

There is no accepted viticultural impact of comets on grapevines, and there have been many successful vintages throughout the world in years where there were no noticeable comet sightings.^[1] Over centuries a great number of events and phenomena have been attributed to the appearances of comets in the sky—such as devastating earthquakes, a 1668 epidemic among cats in Westphalia, or an increase in the birth of twins in a particular area. While many of the phenomena associated with comets tend to be negative, the association of comets and wine has almost always been held as beneficial by viticulturists and oenologists.^[5]

1811 vintage

Despite officially banning the importation of bottled French wines, such as Champagne, Tsar Alexander I was said to have sought out the Veuve Clicquot Cuvée de la Comète

The 1811 comet vintage has had the most lasting notoriety. The comet that year was the Flaugergues comet, named after Honoré Flaugergues who first spotted the comet in March. The comet was visible for most of the growing season, which saw optimal conditions for many of the world's major growing regions, but particularly for France. After a string of bad vintages at the start of the 19th century, the 1811 vintage was a reversal of fortune in regions like Bordeaux, Cognac, Champagne and Sauternes. For Cognac, the vintage was considered one of the greatest in history, with many producers today including images of stars on their labels as a homage to the 1811 vintage. Notable wines from this include the 1811 Château d'Yquem, which received a perfect 100-point wine rating by wine critic Robert Parker at a 1996 tasting over one hundred and eighty years after it was bottled.^[2] In Germany, the 1811 vintage was so successful that producers along the Rhine would label their wines as "comet hock".^[1]

The 1811 bottling of vintage Champagne from the Champagne house of Veuve Clicquot has been theorized to have been the first truly "modern" Champagne. The wine was one of the first to be described as "limpid" or sediment-free.^[2]^[4] This was due to the new technique of remuage or riddling developed by Veuve Cliquot that tackled the historical problem of how to remove the ill tasting and unpleasant looking sediments from the sparkling wine without losing the carbon-dioxide gas that makes it bubble. The development of riddling was a hallmark moment in the evolution of the modern Champagne industry. In the early 19th century, Veuve Clicquot tried to keep their techniques a secret, but the clarity and limpidity of their Champagne captured worldwide attention and eventually their secret escaped.^[6] In the summer of 1812, following Napoleon's invasion of Russia, despite a decree from Tsar Alexander I of Russia banning the importation of French wine in bottles, Louis Bohne, lead sales agent for Veuve Clicquot, was able to smuggle a large quantity of the 1811 Cuvée de la Comète into Königsberg. As word of the wine's quality spread, Bohne found eager customers among the Russian elite,^[7] with even the Tsar himself seeking out the wine.^[6]

Literary references

There have been several references in literature to the 1811 vintage, which was often described as the "Year of the Comet". It is referenced in the title of Ray Russell's 1967 short story "Comet Wine", and the vintage contributes to the story's plot.^[8] Ernst Jünger's 1939 novel On the Marble Cliffs has central characters drinking wine from the "year of the comet". In "The Adventure of the Stockbroker's Clerk" by Arthur Conan Doyle, Dr. Watson describes Sherlock Holmes, upon being told the clerk's story, as being pleased, "like a connoisseur who has just taken his first sip of a comet vintage."^[2] In the 1992 romantic comedy Year of the Comet, a bottle of 1811 Château Lafite is central to the story line.^[9] In The Uncommercial Traveller Charles Dickens refers to a clergyman as one "acquainted with 'Twenty port and comet vintages".

Other notable comet vintages

During its 1986 return Halley's Comet was visible in late 1985 which has been called a "comet vintage"

The 1858 comet vintage attributed to the Donati Comet was widely praised for the quality of Bordeaux claret that came out of that vintage. The 1874 comet vintage was considered especially favorable for the German wine regions of the Mosel and Rheingau.^[10]

1826 — Biela's Comet
1832 — Biela's Comet
1839 — Biela's Comet
1845 — Great June Comet of 1845
1846 — Biela's Comet
1852 — Biela's Comet
1858 — Comet Donati
1861 — Great Comet of 1861
1874 — Comet Coggia
1985 — Halley's Comet
1989 — Comet Okazaki-Levy-Rudenko

References

^ ^a ^b ^c The New York Times archives (August 13, 1872). The Comet
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e G. Harding "A Wine Miscellany" pg 45–47, Clarkson Potter Publishing, New York 2005 ISBN 0-307-34635-8
^ Brewer's Dictionary "Comet wine^{[permanent dead link‍]}" Accessed: December 20th, 2008
^ ^a ^b Johnson, Hugh (1989) Vintage: The Story of Wine. Simon and Schuster. pp. 337. ISBN 0-671-68702-6
^ The New York Times archives (July 19, 1874). The Spectre of the Skies
^ ^a ^b Johnson, Hugh (1989) Vintage: The Story of Wine. Simon and Schuster. pp. 330–341. ISBN 0-671-68702-6
^ Don and Petie Kladstrup, Champagne: How the World’s Most Glamorous Wine Triumphed Over War and Hard Times (New York: William Morrow, 2005), p. 83–84 ISBN 0-06-073792-1.
^ Russell, Ray (27 September 2016). Haunted Castles: The Complete Gothic Stories. ISBN 978-0143129318.
^ Van Gelder, Lawrence, The New York Times, (June 21, 1991). At the Movies: Wine as Hero
^ The New York Times archives (August 27, 1874). Influence of the comet on the German vintage

[Times_1872-1] The New York Times archives (August 13, 1872). The Comet

[Miscellany-2] G. Harding "A Wine Miscellany" pg 45–47, Clarkson Potter Publishing, New York 2005 ISBN 0-307-34635-8

[3] Brewer's Dictionary "Comet wine^{[permanent dead link‍]}" Accessed: December 20th, 2008

[Johnson_pg_337-4] Johnson, Hugh (1989) Vintage: The Story of Wine. Simon and Schuster. pp. 337. ISBN 0-671-68702-6

[5] The New York Times archives (July 19, 1874). The Spectre of the Skies

[Johnson_pg_330–341-6] Johnson, Hugh (1989) Vintage: The Story of Wine. Simon and Schuster. pp. 330–341. ISBN 0-671-68702-6

[7] Don and Petie Kladstrup, Champagne: How the World’s Most Glamorous Wine Triumphed Over War and Hard Times (New York: William Morrow, 2005), p. 83–84 ISBN 0-06-073792-1.

[8] Russell, Ray (27 September 2016). Haunted Castles: The Complete Gothic Stories. ISBN 978-0143129318.

[9] Van Gelder, Lawrence, The New York Times, (June 21, 1991). At the Movies: Wine as Hero

[10] The New York Times archives (August 27, 1874). Influence of the comet on the German vintage

[1]