What do you think?
Rate this book
The Lords of Bucknall Club #2
A Case for Christmas
He loves no-one and never will.
Lord Christmas Gale is a genius and a misanthrope, and, quite to his disgust, adored by all of Society for his capacity to solve mysteries. When a man approaches him seeking help in locating a lost dog, Gale rebuffs him. But what begins with a missing dog ends in murder and intrigue--two of Gale's favourite things, if it weren't for the orphan that comes attached to them. Oh, and Benjamin Chant.
He has sworn to never love again.
The Honourable Mr. Benjamin Chant isn't sure how he got swept up in Gale's mad investigation, but there's something intriguing about the man--a vulnerability that most of the world doesn't notice, but which captures Chant's interest, and his sympathy, from their first meeting. After a disastrous love affair in the past, Chant has sworn to never give his heart away again. Especially to a man who does not want it.
But it isn't just their hearts at stake.
When their investigation takes a dangerous turn and their lives are threatened, both Gale and Chant are forced into the realisation that perhaps two imperfect men might fit perfectly together--that is, if they can outwit the killer who is intent on seeing them both dead.
A Case for Christmas is the second book in the Lords of Bucknall Club series, where the Regency meets m/m romance
Lord Christmas Gale is a genius and a misanthrope, and, quite to his disgust, adored by all of Society for his capacity to solve mysteries. When a man approaches him seeking help in locating a lost dog, Gale rebuffs him. But what begins with a missing dog ends in murder and intrigue--two of Gale's favourite things, if it weren't for the orphan that comes attached to them. Oh, and Benjamin Chant.
He has sworn to never love again.
The Honourable Mr. Benjamin Chant isn't sure how he got swept up in Gale's mad investigation, but there's something intriguing about the man--a vulnerability that most of the world doesn't notice, but which captures Chant's interest, and his sympathy, from their first meeting. After a disastrous love affair in the past, Chant has sworn to never give his heart away again. Especially to a man who does not want it.
But it isn't just their hearts at stake.
When their investigation takes a dangerous turn and their lives are threatened, both Gale and Chant are forced into the realisation that perhaps two imperfect men might fit perfectly together--that is, if they can outwit the killer who is intent on seeing them both dead.
A Case for Christmas is the second book in the Lords of Bucknall Club series, where the Regency meets m/m romance
274 pages, Kindle Edition
First published July 13, 2021
About the author
J.A. Rock
51 books547 followersJ.A. Rock is the author or coauthor of over twenty LGBTQ romance, suspense, and horror novels, as well as an occasional contributor to HuffPo Queer Voices. J.A. has received Lambda Literary and INDIEFAB Award nominations for MINOTAUR, and THE SUBS CLUB received the 2016 National Leather Association-International Pauline Reage Novel Award. J.A. lives in Chicago with an extremely judgmental dog, Professor Anne Studebaker.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 125 reviews
November 21, 2023
4.25 🌟
Wow, what an exceptional collaboration these authors make ! Apparently I started with the third book and I loved it (though I didn’t even remember) .
This was absolutely exquisite from the writing to the complex and amazing characters. Loved loved these guys! I adored Lord Christmas Gale, a misanthrope and a mystery-solving genius and who in my humble and untrained opinion was on the spectrum. And how can I not love the kind and tender Benjamin Chant with his sad past and his need for love.Rich in period details, beautiful writing, awesome mystery case, gentle, quiet and unique love story, interesting side characters (adored Gale’s mother) , witty dialogues with subtle humor and a perfect grumpy/kind historical book.
The only niggle and the reason I couldn’t give it 5 stars was that I needed to see them more intimate with each other, I needed some sensual moments between them. They had a mind and heart bond but I wanted more of that sexual chemistry. Many ppl won’t be bothered by this so I totally recommend this if you’re looking for a good (alternate)historical/mild mystery.
Wow, what an exceptional collaboration these authors make ! Apparently I started with the third book and I loved it (though I didn’t even remember) .
This was absolutely exquisite from the writing to the complex and amazing characters. Loved loved these guys! I adored Lord Christmas Gale, a misanthrope and a mystery-solving genius and who in my humble and untrained opinion was on the spectrum. And how can I not love the kind and tender Benjamin Chant with his sad past and his need for love.Rich in period details, beautiful writing, awesome mystery case, gentle, quiet and unique love story, interesting side characters (adored Gale’s mother) , witty dialogues with subtle humor and a perfect grumpy/kind historical book.
The only niggle and the reason I couldn’t give it 5 stars was that I needed to see them more intimate with each other, I needed some sensual moments between them. They had a mind and heart bond but I wanted more of that sexual chemistry. Many ppl won’t be bothered by this so I totally recommend this if you’re looking for a good (alternate)historical/mild mystery.
November 16, 2023
I'd recommend starting this series with this book. While the first book was good, this one is like a Sherlock Holmes mystery where Holmes and Watson hook up... and then adopt a child! Basically I was the exact target audience.
November 28, 2021
“I almost have de Cock where I want him,” Gale said. “And, for the love of God, please do not ask if that is in my arse.”
Ah, the jokes about a certain male body part in this book are just divine.
Ah, the jokes about a certain male body part in this book are just divine.
December 7, 2021
3.5
The story takes place in an alternate Regency London where an Marriage Act Amendment was introduced to allow same-sex marriages in attempt to lighten the burden of too many legal heirs – but surely also to lighten the mood of the readers because that way they are able to enjoy the vibe of that era without concern about the possible consequences of its homophobia.
We remember Lord Christmas Gale from the previous book which I didn't enjoy much because of issues I had with one of its MCs. Now also Gale doesn't appear as the most likable romance character, cultivate misanthrope he pretends to be. His cynical grumpiness and his need to hide behind nonchalant banter makes him a perfect Henry/Rock character and the authors don't spare him awkward situations and devastating moments when his brusque manners offends all social sensibilities. Seems to me he's suffering of at least a light form of autism and needs to keep the world at bay without making his real and imagined lacking too obvious.
"What did one do when one had firmly rejected the world again and again and then found himself too proud to ask to be let back in?"
The Honourable Mr. Benjamin Chant seems to be his complete antipode with his sunny kindness and forgivable friendliness but of course to a certain degree that's also only a front to deal with society and the part where Gale makes him aware that he's not completely honest with himself about his reasons for a relationship is simply perfect in balancing their characters. Such honesty kindly delivered by someone socially challenged is rare in romance.
Do not fear that this is overly angsty or a dragging study about healing insecurities and past damages. The mystery investigation, Gale's eccentric non-friends, his lively family, a parade of dogs and his loving matriarch of a mother won't let that happen and even in those situations when Gale's and Chant's relationship progress seems to come to a standstill there is banter or comfort around the next corner.
The story takes place in an alternate Regency London where an Marriage Act Amendment was introduced to allow same-sex marriages in attempt to lighten the burden of too many legal heirs – but surely also to lighten the mood of the readers because that way they are able to enjoy the vibe of that era without concern about the possible consequences of its homophobia.
We remember Lord Christmas Gale from the previous book which I didn't enjoy much because of issues I had with one of its MCs. Now also Gale doesn't appear as the most likable romance character, cultivate misanthrope he pretends to be. His cynical grumpiness and his need to hide behind nonchalant banter makes him a perfect Henry/Rock character and the authors don't spare him awkward situations and devastating moments when his brusque manners offends all social sensibilities. Seems to me he's suffering of at least a light form of autism and needs to keep the world at bay without making his real and imagined lacking too obvious.
"What did one do when one had firmly rejected the world again and again and then found himself too proud to ask to be let back in?"
The Honourable Mr. Benjamin Chant seems to be his complete antipode with his sunny kindness and forgivable friendliness but of course to a certain degree that's also only a front to deal with society and the part where Gale makes him aware that he's not completely honest with himself about his reasons for a relationship is simply perfect in balancing their characters. Such honesty kindly delivered by someone socially challenged is rare in romance.
Do not fear that this is overly angsty or a dragging study about healing insecurities and past damages. The mystery investigation, Gale's eccentric non-friends, his lively family, a parade of dogs and his loving matriarch of a mother won't let that happen and even in those situations when Gale's and Chant's relationship progress seems to come to a standstill there is banter or comfort around the next corner.
September 7, 2021
For those of you who had been reading these series in order ( I have read this book first and then the second book), we met grumpy Lord Christmas Gale in the first book when he helps one of the main characters to investigate some stuff. Apparently his hobby becomes more than a hobby for him when more and more people get to know about his investigative skills . Only in this book Lord Gale ( obviously he hates being called Christmas, I would have too) stumbles upon murder and drags Benjamin Chant in to help him .
This is once again a society where the same sex marriages are supposed to be encouraged between the younger sons and daughters of the British nobility to decrease the amount of heirs and I thought this book did a much better job to show that the society itself accepts same sex relationships pretty well.
Gale's mother not only takes it as absolute matter of fact when her son seems fond of another man ( more importantly another man is found of him), but when one of her daughters gets an offer from another woman. More importantly no one seems to have a problem with the hero not really hiding his preference for men.
I thought Gale and Chant were really sweet together. Now, Gale can be really really prickly - but I thought this was explained really well, and his awkwardness notwithstanding I loved Gale very much right away and had no problem empathizing with some difficulties he may have had communicating with the world around him . The authors thank goodness did not attempt to explain it in contemporary language, but they talk about Gale not always understanding what people around him were feeling and how to related to that. I suspect that they once again wanted to portray Asberger syndrome but I cannot be sure and everyone can interpret on their own of course.
Chant also was a sweetheart and had some of his own issues, but I thought together the men had great chemistry.
Why 3.5 stars? well I don't think it is a bad grade, but I thought the mystery was awkward at best - enough for give the men something to do, but not enough to be considered a real mystery in my opinion. Oh we are suspecting somebody to be a bad guy? YAY he really is a bad guy and here is a detailed explanation of their motivations.
This is once again a society where the same sex marriages are supposed to be encouraged between the younger sons and daughters of the British nobility to decrease the amount of heirs and I thought this book did a much better job to show that the society itself accepts same sex relationships pretty well.
Gale's mother not only takes it as absolute matter of fact when her son seems fond of another man ( more importantly another man is found of him), but when one of her daughters gets an offer from another woman. More importantly no one seems to have a problem with the hero not really hiding his preference for men.
I thought Gale and Chant were really sweet together. Now, Gale can be really really prickly - but I thought this was explained really well, and his awkwardness notwithstanding I loved Gale very much right away and had no problem empathizing with some difficulties he may have had communicating with the world around him . The authors thank goodness did not attempt to explain it in contemporary language, but they talk about Gale not always understanding what people around him were feeling and how to related to that. I suspect that they once again wanted to portray Asberger syndrome but I cannot be sure and everyone can interpret on their own of course.
Chant also was a sweetheart and had some of his own issues, but I thought together the men had great chemistry.
Why 3.5 stars? well I don't think it is a bad grade, but I thought the mystery was awkward at best - enough for give the men something to do, but not enough to be considered a real mystery in my opinion. Oh we are suspecting somebody to be a bad guy? YAY he really is a bad guy and here is a detailed explanation of their motivations.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Want to read
December 30, 2021Kindle freebie 12/29/21
December 27, 2021
Three things are definite; this book has nothing to do with the festive season, this second book of the series is umpteen times better than the first (IMO), and Christmas Gale is one of the most engaging MCs for me since Linus Baker (The House in the Cerulean Sea) and Martin Grove (His Quiet Agent). Having a great plot, good pacing and really amusing dialogue also helped tremendously - this is what I expect from these authors.
I was compelled to laugh aloud from snarky asides and witty bantering. E.g.
The dance of attraction between Christmas and Benjamin was realistically spaced out and kept me fully engaged in cheering them on despite their brittle awkwardness and seemingly impervious protective emotional armor; but when they finally got their act together - well it was a sight to behold. It was also not too difficult to imagine an alt-history whereby same-sex relationships and marriage were acceptable 18th century socio-cultural norms. But as much as I loved these MCs (and some of the secondary ones as well), I bow down in homage to Lady Gale (Christmas' mother) who stole every scene she was in and who made me cry near the ending.
4.5 stars for a thoroughly engaging tale that kept me fully entertained for several hours.
I was compelled to laugh aloud from snarky asides and witty bantering. E.g.
“It’s a sign of the apocalypse is what it is,” a young lady announced, sweeping into the room in a whirl of ribbons and curls and a cloud of sweet perfume. “Christmas made a friend!”Significant double entendre mileage was also made from our MCs having to chase after a malevolent character named De Cock!
The dance of attraction between Christmas and Benjamin was realistically spaced out and kept me fully engaged in cheering them on despite their brittle awkwardness and seemingly impervious protective emotional armor; but when they finally got their act together - well it was a sight to behold. It was also not too difficult to imagine an alt-history whereby same-sex relationships and marriage were acceptable 18th century socio-cultural norms. But as much as I loved these MCs (and some of the secondary ones as well), I bow down in homage to Lady Gale (Christmas' mother) who stole every scene she was in and who made me cry near the ending.
4.5 stars for a thoroughly engaging tale that kept me fully entertained for several hours.
July 21, 2021
3.25 stars
We met Christmas in the previous book. After the events, he has made a name for himself as an investigator much to his chargin. He finds himself embroiled in another case this time murder. He also finds himself with Chant, a fellow he met at a ball, assisting him. Problem is Gale finds Chant to be quite the distraction.
Likes:
Chant he is immediately likable.
Gale once you get passed his exterior.
Gale's family. His father and eldest brother are away so Gale is surrounded by women. He may appear aloof about them but that's just Gales M.O.
The mystery. Going through the case withe Gale and Chant to discover the story of Howe's murder.
Dislike:
I ended up liking Gale enough but it does take sometime to warm up to him.
Overall a decent read.
*ARC was provided by GRR, this is my honest review.*
We met Christmas in the previous book. After the events, he has made a name for himself as an investigator much to his chargin. He finds himself embroiled in another case this time murder. He also finds himself with Chant, a fellow he met at a ball, assisting him. Problem is Gale finds Chant to be quite the distraction.
Likes:
Chant he is immediately likable.
Gale once you get passed his exterior.
Gale's family. His father and eldest brother are away so Gale is surrounded by women. He may appear aloof about them but that's just Gales M.O.
The mystery. Going through the case withe Gale and Chant to discover the story of Howe's murder.
Dislike:
I ended up liking Gale enough but it does take sometime to warm up to him.
Overall a decent read.
*ARC was provided by GRR, this is my honest review.*
December 5, 2022
ugh I stayed up way into the small hours the night before work because I loved this so much, it was such a lovely funny slow burn with lots of trying to figure each other out and hair stroking and then RIGHT AS WE REACHED THE FINISH LINE, we were so close boys, I had to read with my own two tired eyes as Benjamin Chant put Christmas Gale over his knee and SPANKED HIM. now I know there is a market for this, I know some of you are really into the spanking thing and you know what good for you pal, whatever works for you baby, I’m so happy for you, but good god, I very genuinely recoiled. my EYES SIR. I am but a prudish old lady, I cannot cope.
December 25, 2021
I honestly could have done completely without the romance and just read about Christmas Gale on the case. Chant was a little dull and lifeless in comparison to the neurodivergent, misanthropic Gale. The more involved they got, the less engaged I became with the book.
July 4, 2023
4.5 stars
I haven't read the first book in this series before. I grabbed A Case for Christmas when it was offered free last year on Kindle, and only remembered that I had it, and was interested with the idea of a child on the cover.
I really, REALLY, LOVED this one ... it just gave me a good satisfaction when I reached the last page.
Like I said, I haven't read the first book... so this was the first time I got introduced to the alternate historical universe of The Lords of Bucknall Club and I LIKED IT! Yes, bring all the goodness of being able to be involved in same-sex relationship IN THE PAST without the consequences of being brought to gaol.
And I LOVED the characters. Christmas Gale being a touch of "Sherlock Holmes" in it, with his genius mind, an aversion to socialites, most probably in the spectrum as well. Benjamin Chant, who despite being more "sunshine-y" compared to Gale, hides a broken heart of losing people he loved the most. The two completely FIT and I ADORED the process of them being together. Each SEEING the other and at the same time LEARNING about one another. So, SO GOOD.
Also the supporting characters - like Gale's friends at the Bucknall Club (whom all would get their story, I believe, and I was more intrigued with Soulden and Fernside!) and Gale's sisters, and most notable THE AMAZING Lady Gale. Oh, I LOVED Gale's mother!! It was so good reading a story set in this era (and class), where the parent was VERY SUPPORTIVE and not just thinking about marrying their children. Those scenes between Gale and his mother were just lovely.
The mystery part was not really a mystery. Because we all know who the bad guy was, though the motive of this bad guy wanting a missing dog was the reason that Gale and Chant tried to understand throughout. I guess it wasn't really a mystery but more of a suspense (of trying to avoid this bad guy and find the missing dog).
I wish the story is longer than just one-week timespan though. Because I have never been a fan of the idea "of knowing you're in LOVE within one day/week/month" in romance 😅
I haven't read the first book in this series before. I grabbed A Case for Christmas when it was offered free last year on Kindle, and only remembered that I had it, and was interested with the idea of a child on the cover.
I really, REALLY, LOVED this one ... it just gave me a good satisfaction when I reached the last page.
Like I said, I haven't read the first book... so this was the first time I got introduced to the alternate historical universe of The Lords of Bucknall Club and I LIKED IT! Yes, bring all the goodness of being able to be involved in same-sex relationship IN THE PAST without the consequences of being brought to gaol.
And I LOVED the characters. Christmas Gale being a touch of "Sherlock Holmes" in it, with his genius mind, an aversion to socialites, most probably in the spectrum as well. Benjamin Chant, who despite being more "sunshine-y" compared to Gale, hides a broken heart of losing people he loved the most. The two completely FIT and I ADORED the process of them being together. Each SEEING the other and at the same time LEARNING about one another. So, SO GOOD.
Also the supporting characters - like Gale's friends at the Bucknall Club (whom all would get their story, I believe, and I was more intrigued with Soulden and Fernside!) and Gale's sisters, and most notable THE AMAZING Lady Gale. Oh, I LOVED Gale's mother!! It was so good reading a story set in this era (and class), where the parent was VERY SUPPORTIVE and not just thinking about marrying their children. Those scenes between Gale and his mother were just lovely.
The mystery part was not really a mystery. Because we all know who the bad guy was, though the motive of this bad guy wanting a missing dog was the reason that Gale and Chant tried to understand throughout. I guess it wasn't really a mystery but more of a suspense (of trying to avoid this bad guy and find the missing dog).
I wish the story is longer than just one-week timespan though. Because I have never been a fan of the idea "of knowing you're in LOVE within one day/week/month" in romance 😅
July 10, 2021
I had lackluster feelings about the first book in this series but was thoroughly intrigued by Christmas Gale so had to pick this one up and I am so glad I did. It was exactly what I’ve come to expect from this author duo, fascinating and complex characters, excellent wit and humor, and a fun, heartfelt, and interesting story. I loved both Gale and Chant, as well as the whole myriad of side characters, all of whom were well drawn and just overall fun. This book is the absolute definition of a grumpy one and a sunshine one with a nefarious but hilariously named villain as well, and just overall a book I’m extremely excited to have read. I could read a whole series about these two as their walls come down and they find the love they definitely deserve.
July 4, 2023
Bardzo przyjemnie mi się czytało.
Była tajemnica, śledztwo i kiełkujący związek między autystycznym i genialnym Christmasem Gale a Benjaminem Chantem, gentlemanem, który po okresie odosobnienia wraca na łono towarzystwa. Jak to arystokraci, obaj panowie to próżniacy, którzy przeżywają swoje życie w klubach i na salonach, a w międzyczasie znajdują sobie zabijające czas zajęcia.
Zajęciem Gale'a jest rozwiązywanie zagadek kryminalnych, w czym jest bardzo dobry. Chant właściwie nie wiadomo czym się zajmuje, ale jest miłym, dobrym człowiekiem, nieco poturbowanym przez życie. Obaj bohaterowie mają dysfunkcje i problemy, które sprawiają, że idealnie do siebie pasują.
Sposób, w jaki rodzi się relacja, jest inny niż jesteśmy przyzwyczajeni we współczesnym MM - autorki zadbały, żeby historię przedstawić w dobrze zaprojektowanym parahistorycznym stylu.
Podobało mi się i na pewno przeczytam kolejne części.
Była tajemnica, śledztwo i kiełkujący związek między autystycznym i genialnym Christmasem Gale a Benjaminem Chantem, gentlemanem, który po okresie odosobnienia wraca na łono towarzystwa. Jak to arystokraci, obaj panowie to próżniacy, którzy przeżywają swoje życie w klubach i na salonach, a w międzyczasie znajdują sobie zabijające czas zajęcia.
Zajęciem Gale'a jest rozwiązywanie zagadek kryminalnych, w czym jest bardzo dobry. Chant właściwie nie wiadomo czym się zajmuje, ale jest miłym, dobrym człowiekiem, nieco poturbowanym przez życie. Obaj bohaterowie mają dysfunkcje i problemy, które sprawiają, że idealnie do siebie pasują.
Sposób, w jaki rodzi się relacja, jest inny niż jesteśmy przyzwyczajeni we współczesnym MM - autorki zadbały, żeby historię przedstawić w dobrze zaprojektowanym parahistorycznym stylu.
Podobało mi się i na pewno przeczytam kolejne części.
September 6, 2021
3.5 stars
The characters are very much reminiscent of John and Sherlock, and that is really not a bad thing for me, I actually started reading it because of this!
That said the characters quickly develop traits of their own, especially Chant.
I very much liked Gale's struggle to let himself go in spite of all his fears and I thought he was avery interesting character on his own. On the other hand I was not 100% convinced about Chant, maybe it was just me not finding him too interesting.
Honourable mention to Gale's mother, who was a very funny side character.
The plot was not extraordinary and my mind drifted a bit sometimes.
All in all an enjoyable read, but nothing memorable.
The characters are very much reminiscent of John and Sherlock, and that is really not a bad thing for me, I actually started reading it because of this!
That said the characters quickly develop traits of their own, especially Chant.
I very much liked Gale's struggle to let himself go in spite of all his fears and I thought he was avery interesting character on his own. On the other hand I was not 100% convinced about Chant, maybe it was just me not finding him too interesting.
Honourable mention to Gale's mother, who was a very funny side character.
The plot was not extraordinary and my mind drifted a bit sometimes.
All in all an enjoyable read, but nothing memorable.
July 15, 2021
A Joyfully Jay review.
4.25 stars
A Case for Christmas is the second book in the Lords of Bucknall Club series and I really enjoyed it. Christmas Gale totally stole the show for me as a side character in the first book, A Husband for Hartwell, so I was thrilled to see he was getting his own story here. I love seeing the misanthrope find his true love despite himself, so I found the brilliant, grumpy, and somewhat prickly Gale so much fun. Especially when we get to see his soft underbelly as he begins to open up to Chant. Gale is one of those brilliant people who is so in their own head that they often don’t know how to interact with others. There is a bit of a “grumpy one falls for the sunshiney one” vibe here, as Chant is endlessly patient and upbeat, even in the face of Gale’s occasional rudeness (though he rarely means to be rude, he just has no real idea how to people). But there is also a lot of depth to Chant that we uncover as the story goes on, and we learn that much of his smiling personality is a cover for some inner pain he is trying to hide.
Read Jay’s review in its entirety here.
4.25 stars
A Case for Christmas is the second book in the Lords of Bucknall Club series and I really enjoyed it. Christmas Gale totally stole the show for me as a side character in the first book, A Husband for Hartwell, so I was thrilled to see he was getting his own story here. I love seeing the misanthrope find his true love despite himself, so I found the brilliant, grumpy, and somewhat prickly Gale so much fun. Especially when we get to see his soft underbelly as he begins to open up to Chant. Gale is one of those brilliant people who is so in their own head that they often don’t know how to interact with others. There is a bit of a “grumpy one falls for the sunshiney one” vibe here, as Chant is endlessly patient and upbeat, even in the face of Gale’s occasional rudeness (though he rarely means to be rude, he just has no real idea how to people). But there is also a lot of depth to Chant that we uncover as the story goes on, and we learn that much of his smiling personality is a cover for some inner pain he is trying to hide.
Read Jay’s review in its entirety here.
February 8, 2022
This was a hard book to rate. I didn't think it would be more than 3.5 stars, but as I read, the characters and the story grew and grew and grew into something lovely.
Lord Christmas Gale is the Columbo of the ton, and he has a degree of public attention for it. The papers like to feature his latest success, so anonymity is something he isn't afforded anymore. However, Christmas is, by today’s terminology, neurodivergent/neuroatypical. He is different, uncomfortable around people, socially awkward and seemingly brusque. Basically, he marches to the beat of his own drum. He’s not fond of people, feels he should be better at it for a moment when life impacts on him in some way, then realises he just doesn't care enough, until the Honourable Benjamin Chant comes into his life. Chant gets swept up in Gale’s investigation and under Gale's skin in ways no one else ever has. but it isn't a conscious or quick romance. Chant knows he has feelings not too long after meeting Gale and taking him onto the porch when the latest soiree gets a bit too overwhelming for Christmas.
This story features a dead father, a murdered pirate/privateer, a sinister privateer on the loose, a missing dog, and a newly orphaned young girl for Gale and Chant to contend with. Then there is Gale’s whirlwind of a family, consisting of 5(?) sisters and a mother who are at home while his brother and father travel a lot. They are a wonderfully accepting, loving, liberal thinking, and patient clan, completely full of life and verve.
I’ve really taken to this series with gusto. Rock and Henry do a great job of making these individual books fun and fresh - each book has uniquely individual characters while weaving past and new characters into the mix.
Lord Christmas Gale is the Columbo of the ton, and he has a degree of public attention for it. The papers like to feature his latest success, so anonymity is something he isn't afforded anymore. However, Christmas is, by today’s terminology, neurodivergent/neuroatypical. He is different, uncomfortable around people, socially awkward and seemingly brusque. Basically, he marches to the beat of his own drum. He’s not fond of people, feels he should be better at it for a moment when life impacts on him in some way, then realises he just doesn't care enough, until the Honourable Benjamin Chant comes into his life. Chant gets swept up in Gale’s investigation and under Gale's skin in ways no one else ever has. but it isn't a conscious or quick romance. Chant knows he has feelings not too long after meeting Gale and taking him onto the porch when the latest soiree gets a bit too overwhelming for Christmas.
This story features a dead father, a murdered pirate/privateer, a sinister privateer on the loose, a missing dog, and a newly orphaned young girl for Gale and Chant to contend with. Then there is Gale’s whirlwind of a family, consisting of 5(?) sisters and a mother who are at home while his brother and father travel a lot. They are a wonderfully accepting, loving, liberal thinking, and patient clan, completely full of life and verve.
I’ve really taken to this series with gusto. Rock and Henry do a great job of making these individual books fun and fresh - each book has uniquely individual characters while weaving past and new characters into the mix.
July 13, 2021
This was an utterly entertaining book. It grabbed my attention from the first pages, keeping me engrossed in a clever plot and easy flowing narrative. Set in a Regency-like world, the authors managed to balance mystery and high stakes suspense with lighthearted banter and swoony moments.
All the characters were interesting and I was completely charmed by the protagonists. Gale and Chant were compelling and real, with enough flaws 𝘢𝘯𝘥 redeeming qualities. The development of their relationship was complicated, a rollercoaster of tangled feelings, distrust, genuine like and sizzling chemistry. They've been through a lot and they gave me so, so much emotionally. My heart ached occasionally, I swooned and sighed, and I lost count of the times they made me smile and laugh.
Their story was full of heart, intrigue and humor. I loved it and I can't recommend it enough.
All the characters were interesting and I was completely charmed by the protagonists. Gale and Chant were compelling and real, with enough flaws 𝘢𝘯𝘥 redeeming qualities. The development of their relationship was complicated, a rollercoaster of tangled feelings, distrust, genuine like and sizzling chemistry. They've been through a lot and they gave me so, so much emotionally. My heart ached occasionally, I swooned and sighed, and I lost count of the times they made me smile and laugh.
Their story was full of heart, intrigue and humor. I loved it and I can't recommend it enough.
July 5, 2021
Oh, I thoroughly enjoyed this.
The plot is intriguing and engaging, the characters are memorable. There's a definite Sherlock (the BBC version with Benedict Cumberbatch) vibe to this, if John and Sherlock were Regency era gentlemen in love, which I appreciated.
I loved the beautiful, genuine character growth that both characters go through: Gale's path to acceptance of himself as able to love and be loved, and Chants emotional growth are really well written.
There is also a deliciously low brow (in the best way) running joke involving the villain, which is well executed and not overdone. This, along with Gale's and Chant's witty conversation and the way they inspire fun in each other, adds some levity to a story to could have been quite dark otherwise.
This is the second book in The Lords of Bucknall Club series by these authors, but can be read as a standalone.
I received a copy of this book from Gay Romance Reviews and I have chosen to leave an honest review.
The plot is intriguing and engaging, the characters are memorable. There's a definite Sherlock (the BBC version with Benedict Cumberbatch) vibe to this, if John and Sherlock were Regency era gentlemen in love, which I appreciated.
I loved the beautiful, genuine character growth that both characters go through: Gale's path to acceptance of himself as able to love and be loved, and Chants emotional growth are really well written.
There is also a deliciously low brow (in the best way) running joke involving the villain, which is well executed and not overdone. This, along with Gale's and Chant's witty conversation and the way they inspire fun in each other, adds some levity to a story to could have been quite dark otherwise.
This is the second book in The Lords of Bucknall Club series by these authors, but can be read as a standalone.
I received a copy of this book from Gay Romance Reviews and I have chosen to leave an honest review.
July 11, 2021
4-4.5 stars.
This is the second in the Lords of Bucknall Club series, it can be read as a standalone but Christmas is introduced in the first book, and he pretty much stole it so I'd recommend it as an introduction to the world created here.
Briefly this is an AU Regency world where same sex relationships and marriage are looked upon the same as heterosexual ones, it's not an issue.
Words I rarely speak, let alone write. I love Christmas. He stole the first book for me and I was more than delighted when I found out he would be the focus of the second book. At first I thought he was a mere Sherlock clone and while there are elements of Sherlock in him, he's far more layered than that. He's such a complex character, with elements of social anxiety and I think partly being on the autistic scale as he doesn't pick up social cues often and doesn't like to be touched. All that aside though, I love Christmas. He deserves to be happy and I'm glad he found Chant. Chant's been through a lot too and he's the perfect foil for Christmas, loving and cheerful where Christmas is prone to morose and withdrawn, although they both have their moments.
Their love story is set around an investigation (not a case, for heaven's sake) all to do with murder, dogs, ragamuffin children and pirates. It's all a rather fun romp, all told. I liked the first book fine, this is much better though. Mostly because of Christmas.
I received an ARC from GRR and this is my honest review.
This is the second in the Lords of Bucknall Club series, it can be read as a standalone but Christmas is introduced in the first book, and he pretty much stole it so I'd recommend it as an introduction to the world created here.
Briefly this is an AU Regency world where same sex relationships and marriage are looked upon the same as heterosexual ones, it's not an issue.
Words I rarely speak, let alone write. I love Christmas. He stole the first book for me and I was more than delighted when I found out he would be the focus of the second book. At first I thought he was a mere Sherlock clone and while there are elements of Sherlock in him, he's far more layered than that. He's such a complex character, with elements of social anxiety and I think partly being on the autistic scale as he doesn't pick up social cues often and doesn't like to be touched. All that aside though, I love Christmas. He deserves to be happy and I'm glad he found Chant. Chant's been through a lot too and he's the perfect foil for Christmas, loving and cheerful where Christmas is prone to morose and withdrawn, although they both have their moments.
Their love story is set around an investigation (not a case, for heaven's sake) all to do with murder, dogs, ragamuffin children and pirates. It's all a rather fun romp, all told. I liked the first book fine, this is much better though. Mostly because of Christmas.
I received an ARC from GRR and this is my honest review.
January 17, 2024
Gossshhh I love this series! This book was a bit darker than the other 2 I have read so far, but I really enjoyed it - definitely had Sherlock vibes mixed with the usual Bridgerton drama!
Lord Christmas Gale is famous across the ton for solving mysteries. When one evening a drunk man comes to him asking with help finding a missing dog, Gale sends him on his way without a second thought… however when the man shortly turns up murdered, seemingly over the missing dog, Gale is concerned about the murdered man’s daughter. Enlisting the help of The Honourable Benjamin Chant, whom he befriended at a society ball, Gale and Chang goe to find the girl and stumble headfast into a murder mystery with pirates, jewels and of course, that damned missing dog!
This one was so much fun!
✨Murder mystery
✨Amateur sleuth and sidekick
✨Neurodivergent rep (unnamed, but reads as autism)
✨Hair stroking
✨Totally oblivious to each others feelings
✨Loving supportive family (Gale’s mum is MVP)
Lord Christmas Gale is famous across the ton for solving mysteries. When one evening a drunk man comes to him asking with help finding a missing dog, Gale sends him on his way without a second thought… however when the man shortly turns up murdered, seemingly over the missing dog, Gale is concerned about the murdered man’s daughter. Enlisting the help of The Honourable Benjamin Chant, whom he befriended at a society ball, Gale and Chang goe to find the girl and stumble headfast into a murder mystery with pirates, jewels and of course, that damned missing dog!
This one was so much fun!
✨Murder mystery
✨Amateur sleuth and sidekick
✨Neurodivergent rep (unnamed, but reads as autism)
✨Hair stroking
✨Totally oblivious to each others feelings
✨Loving supportive family (Gale’s mum is MVP)
August 21, 2021
The Lords of Bucknall series continues with a second story set in the interesting fantasy Regency world wherein gay relationships are readily accepted but the rules of polite society still reign. A Case for Christmas was a great combination of an investigative mystery and a low-key, slow-burn romance.
Once again, these authors delivered a story with an easy flow and an interesting array of characters. I really liked Christmas and Chant, but it was the interesting case Christmas set upon solving that truly hooked me. There were a number of twists and revelations that kept me invested along the way. Furthermore, I loved how the secondary characters impacted the story, casually revealing aspects of both men to further develop their personalities and draw out the men's feelings for one another. In the first book, I lamented seeing the feelings develop between the men on-page, but that wasn't an issue in A Case for Christmas and it made it easier to root for Chant and Christmas as they explored their interest in one another.
I'd recommend A Case for Christmas to fans of Regency romances or those readers who simply want something different from the norm.
*** Copy provided to Bayou Book Junkie for my reading pleasure, a review wasn't a requirement. ***
Once again, these authors delivered a story with an easy flow and an interesting array of characters. I really liked Christmas and Chant, but it was the interesting case Christmas set upon solving that truly hooked me. There were a number of twists and revelations that kept me invested along the way. Furthermore, I loved how the secondary characters impacted the story, casually revealing aspects of both men to further develop their personalities and draw out the men's feelings for one another. In the first book, I lamented seeing the feelings develop between the men on-page, but that wasn't an issue in A Case for Christmas and it made it easier to root for Chant and Christmas as they explored their interest in one another.
I'd recommend A Case for Christmas to fans of Regency romances or those readers who simply want something different from the norm.
*** Copy provided to Bayou Book Junkie for my reading pleasure, a review wasn't a requirement. ***
July 2, 2021
Lord Christmas Gale and Benjamin Chant, not a match made in heaven.
Gale and Chant, brought together by death, pirates, a whimsical little girl, and a raggedy dog. Both terribly interested in each other but incapable of figuring out how to go about expressing those feelings.
This was a nice story with some angsty moments. Gale’s family were a perfect foil for his grumpiness. Adding a vulnerable little girl to the mix and he was lost.
I liked Gale and Chant’s interactions. Their encounters were sweet and not overly explicit, but that’s not to say they weren’t very interesting.
Cute story with a little death and mayhem.
I received an arc of this book.
Gale and Chant, brought together by death, pirates, a whimsical little girl, and a raggedy dog. Both terribly interested in each other but incapable of figuring out how to go about expressing those feelings.
This was a nice story with some angsty moments. Gale’s family were a perfect foil for his grumpiness. Adding a vulnerable little girl to the mix and he was lost.
I liked Gale and Chant’s interactions. Their encounters were sweet and not overly explicit, but that’s not to say they weren’t very interesting.
Cute story with a little death and mayhem.
I received an arc of this book.
November 23, 2023
This is my first "HenRock" book (J.A. Rock and Lisa Henry) and I enjoyed it. It treaded the line between comedy and serious murder mystery, incorporating both into the story. Both main characters have some issues that make things interesting. Gale is what we would call neurodivergent and Chant comes across as a dear, but has past family tragedy and a relationship breakdown that he's still dealing with. I like the way the authors dealt with those issues. The story did feel a little choppy at times, and I found myself wondering if it's because of having two authors, but I have no idea. I'd definitely be open to reading more books by this author duo.
July 16, 2021
I'm not normally a historical fan but I'm loving this The Lords of Bucknall Club series. It's like a really good BBC period drama, with a hint of Bridgerton but with all the yummy MM goodness.
I adored Gale. He was Mr Grumpy to Benjamin's sunshine. But he had good reason. He spent so much time being hassled by people wanting something from him. Gale was also so starved of touch and affectation. I just wanted to hug hum, but you'd know he hate that.
What I really like in a good romance is the banter between the MCs and Gale & Benjamin had it in spades and I loved it. Plus there was also lots of swoony heart melting moments. Throw in the murder suspense plot and this was the perfect story.
I adored Gale. He was Mr Grumpy to Benjamin's sunshine. But he had good reason. He spent so much time being hassled by people wanting something from him. Gale was also so starved of touch and affectation. I just wanted to hug hum, but you'd know he hate that.
What I really like in a good romance is the banter between the MCs and Gale & Benjamin had it in spades and I loved it. Plus there was also lots of swoony heart melting moments. Throw in the murder suspense plot and this was the perfect story.
July 16, 2021
Try
It’s Christmas in July! I wanted this story from the moment I met this jaded, prickly grump and it was brilliant. Chant, who has some prickly issues of his own, is a wonderful, sunshine-y partner. “You are quite a wonder, you know.” I love these two together. Their banter, their vulnerabilities, their silliness, the way they see inside each other, it all completely charmed me, as did Gale’s family and the mystery behind it all. I’m enchanted with this series and the characters within it, including Hartwell, who has redeemed himself in my eyes. So jugs off to you, have a cup of tea and settle in to read this dashing romance.
It’s Christmas in July! I wanted this story from the moment I met this jaded, prickly grump and it was brilliant. Chant, who has some prickly issues of his own, is a wonderful, sunshine-y partner. “You are quite a wonder, you know.” I love these two together. Their banter, their vulnerabilities, their silliness, the way they see inside each other, it all completely charmed me, as did Gale’s family and the mystery behind it all. I’m enchanted with this series and the characters within it, including Hartwell, who has redeemed himself in my eyes. So jugs off to you, have a cup of tea and settle in to read this dashing romance.
November 2, 2021
I love these characters. Is that only because I'm super ace and often touch averse and Gale is the most resonant character I've seen in a book in a long time? Probably. But Chant's cool too, and their conflict didn't feel drawn out for the sake of plot and more like genuine problems that occurred organically and were worked out realistically... Or as realistically as a super gay alternate reality Victorian London can manage.
September 6, 2022
Lord Christmas Gale is a very grumpy, brusque, and bored Gentleman, who dismisses a request to search for a lost dog. But, here comes Mr Benjamin Chant, a nice, smiley person who promises to help. When a body is discovered, Gale is a little more interested; and intrigued by Chant.
A silly, nice bit of skulduggery, with a satisfactory outcome.
A silly, nice bit of skulduggery, with a satisfactory outcome.
October 3, 2022
I’m in the minority because I liked book 1 more. That had a through line, I knew what it was doing. This felt more muddled with the men going in circles over the same ground a few times. And I didn’t find the (don’t call it a) case that interesting.
May 13, 2024
Someone give that poor dog a bath already!! I can't believe the book ended before we got to see that!
October 24, 2023
very fun, i just wish there was an epilogue because i wanted to see if they actually i was invested in that.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 125 reviews