What do you think?
Rate this book
400 pages, ebook
First published April 1, 2019
*Spoilers beyond here, you've been warned*
There're several issues that bother me:
One, did Libby actually need to be in the room with the other jurors? Her presence felt like a big fat deus ex machina utilized to ensure the reader would care about the ensuing events. It was lazy and unimaginative.
Two, why mastermind an act of revenge, against the system that not only cheated your family of a fortune but also was complicit in the death of three generations of the same family, when other innocent citizens' lives would be in peril? In addition, why those 8 passengers and what were the criteria for choosing them? More importantly, why did the author choose to eliminate, Bilquis and Shabana, the only POCs in the entire story? Did Marrs not understand the racial undertones surrounding that decision, especially in this Brexit nationalistic period, and considering there were several other white characters who could similarly have been eliminated.
Three, why did Noah pretend to be Jude and for that matter, why go through the convoluted process of their initial meeting? It made no sense other than Marrs using that and numerous other coincidences to piece together the fracture within the story. That Libby happened to have witnessed the aforementioned deaths just seemed too convenient. Idk, something about the plot and execution seems convoluted and protracted.
Don't misunderstand I thought the premise, of an Orwellian society with driverless cars, was brilliant. Likewise, the motivation for revenge, yet, the act itself was misplaced and unjustifiable IMO. In comparison, consider Marrs' other book The One (which I loved) wherein the motivation and justification for Matthew's revenge was without question. It just made sense and the punishment for Ellie's complicity matched the crime.
Ultimately, it was certainly a great premise which was let down by the above issues. However, please do not let this stop you from buying the book as this is no more than the opinion of an outlier.
‘”It may have come to your attention that your vehicle is no longer under your management. From here on in, I am in charge of your destination. “'