Simeon Willis

Simeon Willis
46th Governor of Kentucky
In office December 7, 1943 – December 9, 1947
Lieutenant	Kenneth H. Tuggle
Preceded by	Keen Johnson
Succeeded by	Earle Clements
Personal details
Born	Simeon Slavens Willis (1879-12-01)December 1, 1879 Aid Township, Ohio, U.S.
Died	April 2, 1965(1965-04-02) (aged 85) Frankfort, Kentucky, U.S.
Resting place	Frankfort Cemetery
Political party	Republican
Spouse	Ida Lee Millis
Profession	Lawyer

Simeon Slavens Willis (December 1, 1879 – April 1, 1965) was an American attorney who served as the 46th Governor of Kentucky, United States, serving from 1943 to 1947. He was the only Republican elected governor of Kentucky between 1927 and 1967.^[1]

Willis's family came to Kentucky from Ohio about 1889. After briefly working in the education and journalism fields, Willis read law with private tutors and was admitted to the bar in 1901. He became interested in politics, but his early races for office were unsuccessful with the exception of his four-year stint as city solicitor for Ashland, Kentucky. Finally in 1927, newly elected governor Flem D. Sampson appointed Willis to the Kentucky Court of Appeals—then the court of last resort in the state. Willis went on to win a full four-year term on the court in 1928, and distinguished himself by revising Thornton on the Law of Oil and Gas, a six-volume law reference. He was defeated for re-election to his seat in 1932 and returned to his law practice.

After a decade out of politics, Willis was chosen without opposition as the Republican gubernatorial nominee in 1943. Infighting among the state's Democrats, combined with Willis's popular proposal to eliminate the state income tax, carried him to a narrow victory over J. Lyter Donaldson. Willis was opposed by Democratic majorities in both houses of the Kentucky General Assembly. The end of World War II in 1945 brought sizable budget surpluses to the state, and disagreements over how to spend the excess funds spilled over into special legislative sessions. Willis was not able to realize his campaign promise of eliminating the state income tax because the legislature expanded the budget far beyond what he proposed. But he did forge a record of modest accomplishments, including constructing five tuberculosis hospitals across the state and significantly increasing funding for education. Following his term as governor, he served on various state boards and commissions, but failed in his only attempt to return to elective office—a 1952 campaign against Bert T. Combs to return to the Court of Appeals. Willis died on April 1, 1965, and is interred at Frankfort Cemetery in the capital city of Frankfort.

Simeon S. Willis was born on December 1, 1879, in Lawrence County, Ohio, which is located along the Ohio River on the southern border of the state.^[2] He was the youngest of nine children born to John H. and Abigail (Slavens) Willis.^[3] During the Civil War, his grandfather William Willis served as captain of Company C of the 5th West Virginia Infantry of the Union Army, and his father John H. Willis served as a corporal in that company.^[4] Later, John Willis moved to eastern Ohio, where he became a pioneer in the charcoal industry.^[5]

Willis was educated in the public schools of Lawrence County.^[2] About 1889, his family moved across the river to Springville (now South Portsmouth) in Greenup County, Kentucky.^[4] There, Willis again attended the public schools, and took a teacher-training course at a local private school.^[1] Before age 20, he was selected principal of a three-room grade school in Springville.^[3]

Willis also worked as a reporter for the Portsmouth Tribune and an editorial writer for the Greenup Gazette.^[1] He simultaneously read law with private tutors, including future congressman Joseph Bentley Bennett and William Corn, a professor at Ada University.^[3] He was admitted to the bar on November 11, 1901, and in January 1902, he established a law practice in Ashland.^[4][6] Soon after, he joined Hager and Stewart, a prominent law firm in the area, where he worked for six years.^[3] Thereafter, he returned to his own practice.^[3]

Running as a Republican, Willis lost a bid to become city attorney of Ashland in 1905.^[6] In 1916, he ran for a seat on the Kentucky Court of Appeals, but lost in the primary to Flem D. Sampson, who went on to win the general election.^[7] He took a brief leave of politics and served as an appeals agent for the Selective Service System during World War I.^[7] In 1918, he won the election for Ashland city solicitor and served in that position until 1922.^[6] Beginning in 1922, he served on the State Board of Bar Examiners, a position he held until 1928.^[2]

Willis married Ida Lee Millis, a deputy county clerk, on April 14, 1920.^[1][7] The couple had one daughter, Sarah Leslie Willis, born on July 16, 1922.^[8] Ida Willis became the first female executive director of the Kentucky Heritage Commission. In 1979, the Ida Lee Willis Memorial Foundation was created in her honor.^[9]

When Flem D. Sampson was elected governor in 1927, he appointed Willis to fill his seat on the Kentucky Court of Appeals.^[7] In 1928, Willis was elected to a full four-year term representing the Court's Seventh Appellate District.^[1] Holding a state-level office increased his political stature, as did revising Thornton on the Law of Oil and Gas, a six-volume law reference, during his time on the bench.^[7] Given the Democratic surge that swept Franklin D. Roosevelt into the presidency in 1932, Willis was not badly affected by losing his seat on the court to Democrat Alex Ratliff.^[7] Following this defeat, Willis returned to his private practice.^[6]

In 1943, Willis was approached by the Republican Party and was unopposed for the Republican gubernatorial nomination.^[6] The Democrats nominated J. Lyter Donaldson to oppose Willis in a contentious three-way primary.^[10] Willis's decade-long absence from politics worked to his advantage, as he had few ties to the state's established politicians and little in the way of a recent political track record that could be exploited by his opponent.^[10] Donaldson warned against changing the political party in power while World War II was still ongoing, but Willis countered that the soldiers must come home to a better state than the one they left, and that would not occur if the Democratic political machine were allowed to continue in power.^[11] He further proposed abolition of the state income tax, a proposal that was popular with voters, but was derided by the Democratic-leaning Louisville Courier-Journal as a "weird unreality".^[12]

Willis won the general election by a vote of 279,144 to 270,525.^[6] One factor influencing his victory was his ability to regain much of the black vote in urban centers such as Louisville, which had traditionally supported Republican candidates but had in recent years swung Democratic, because of the Republican Party's failure to deliver on campaign promises after winning elections.^[13] Further, factionalism in the Democratic party had hurt Donaldson. Though he enjoyed the support of sitting governor Keen Johnson, Donaldson garnered only lukewarm support from Johnson's predecessor, Senator A. B. "Happy" Chandler.^[12]

Willis was the only Republican elected governor of Kentucky in a 40-year period spanning from 1927 to 1967.^[1] During much of that time, most black residents had been disenfranchised by laws the state passed at the turn of the century. Willis's victory in a traditionally Democratic state in an off-year election brought him national attention, and he was considered as a candidate for vice-president at the 1944 Republican National Convention.^[14]

Governor John W. Bricker of Ohio, who did become the Republican vice-presidential nominee in 1944, had helped Willis in his gubernatorial race. Upon Willis' victory, Bricker wired a friend to express jubilation, which turned out to have been unfounded: "Election showed definite trend in all areas against New Deal. I was not surprised at the outcome particularly in Kentucky because the thinking of the people of the Middle West is in line with results down there. It looks very much like a Republican victory next year."^[15]

Willis faced the challenge of having Democratic majorities in both houses of the General Assembly and strong Democratic leadership in each.^[16] In the House, Democrats held a 56–44 majority, and Harry Lee Waterfield served as Speaker of the House.^[16] In the Senate, Democrats held a 23–15 majority, and the President Pro Tempore of the Senate was Earle C. Clements.^[16] Both Waterfield and Clements were preparing to make gubernatorial runs in 1947.^[16] Willis did not make wholesale dismissals of Democratic appointees at higher levels in the state government, owing in part to shortages of experienced people during the war.^[16] This cost him some Republican support, and both his lieutenant governor and attorney general began to oppose him on many matters.^[14] But his refusal to make wholesale dismissals may have produced more positive relations with the legislature, which did not pass legislation to strip the bulk of his gubernatorial powers, as it had done to Flem D. Sampson, the last Republican governor.^[14]

During Willis's term, state revenue increased because of to wartime inflation, increased federal revenues flowing to the state, and the relative prosperity of the state's economy stimulated by defense spending.^[17] The state budget was $31 million when Willis took office; by the time he left office, it had expanded to $52 million.^[17] Much of these funds were devoted to education. Expenditures per pupil nearly doubled, as did teacher salaries.^[6] The school year was lengthened from seven to eight months.^[6] Counties were also allowed to double their school tax rate.^[6] He created a Commission on Negro Affairs, appointed the first African American to the state Board of Education, and increased state aid to pay out-of-state tuition to minorities who had been denied admission to professional programs in the segregated state universities.^[6]

In the 1944 legislative session, the rival parties fought to a stalemate over the budget. The primary issue was deciding who would control the state's sizable budget surplus—the legislature or the governor. In an effort to unify the two sides, Willis backed off his call for a repeal of the income tax; another legislator proposed the repeal anyway, but it was defeated. Two months after the end of the session, Willis called a special session to reconcile the educational items in the budget. Once in session, legislators approved a full budget. The vote to accept the budget was deemed invalid, however, because approving a full budget was not part of Willis's initial call for a special session. In response, Willis called a second special session, and the Assembly passed a full budget on June 16, 1944.^[16]

Willis renewed his call for an income tax repeal in the 1946 legislative session, but Democrats opposed the repeal and Republicans were split on the issue. The proposal failed by a vote of 36–60. Accomplishments of the session included better mine safety laws and stronger concealed weapons laws, and increased funding for black education in what was still a segregated state. The war's end had brought additional revenue sources, and even with an expanded budget, the state had an $18 million surplus by the end of Willis's term.^[18]

Other accomplishments of Willis's administration included eliminating tolls on twelve of the state's thirteen major bridges, and expanding programs for dependent children and the elderly.^[6] Construction of five state tuberculosis hospitals—at London, Madisonville, Paris, Ashland, and Glasgow—was initiated and nearly 80 percent completed by the end of his term.^[1] Republicans were unable to capitalize on Willis's accomplishments as governor, however.^[19] In the 1947 gubernatorial election, the party fragmented over their choice of gubernatorial nominee, and Democrat Earle C. Clements was elected governor.^[20]

Following his term as governor, Willis returned to his private practice in Ashland.^[2] In 1952, he failed in his bid to return to the Court of Appeals, having lost to Bert T. Combs, who later was elected as governor.^[6] From 1956 to 1960, Willis served as a member of the Kentucky Public Service Commission.^[6]

In 1958, he received a citation for outstanding service to the state bar.^[7] In 1961, he was appointed to the review board authorized by the Veterans' Bonus Act.^[1] Also in 1961, he was appointed to the State Parole Board, a position he held until 1965.^[6]

Willis died on April 2, 1965, and is buried at the Frankfort Cemetery in the state capital.^[2] The Simeon Willis Memorial Bridge over the Ohio River in Ashland is named in his honor.

• Comer, Diane (2008-02-02). "Public encouraged to nominate deserving individuals, projects and organizations". Kentucky Heritage Council. Retrieved 2009-09-30.
• Connelley, William Elsey; Ellis Merton Coulter (1922). Charles Kerr (ed.). History of Kentucky. Vol. 3. The American Historical Society. ISBN 9780598572981. Retrieved 2009-09-28.
• Harrison, Lowell H. (1992). "Willis, Simeon". In Kleber, John E. (ed.). The Kentucky Encyclopedia. Associate editors: Thomas D. Clark, Lowell H. Harrison, and James C. Klotter. Lexington, Kentucky: The University Press of Kentucky. ISBN 0-8131-1772-0.
• Harrison, Lowell H.; James C. Klotter (1997). A New History of Kentucky. University Press of Kentucky. ISBN 0-8131-2008-X. Retrieved 2009-06-26.
• Jillson, Willard Rouse (1944). Governor Simeon S. Willis. C.T. Dearing Printing Company.
• "Kentucky Governor Simeon Slavens Willis". National Governors Association. Archived from the original on 2009-10-20. Retrieved 2009-09-28.
• Klotter, James C. (1996). Kentucky: Portraits in Paradox, 1900–1950. University Press of Kentucky. ISBN 0-916968-24-3. Retrieved 2009-06-26.
• Klotter, James C. (2004). "Simeon Willis". In Lowell Hayes Harrison (ed.). Kentucky's Governors. Lexington, Kentucky: The University Press of Kentucky. ISBN 0-8131-2326-7.
• Powell, Robert A. (1976). Kentucky Governors. Danville, Kentucky: Bluegrass Printing Company. OCLC 2690774.

• Simeon Willis at The Political Graveyard
• Simeon Slavens Willis papers at the University of Kentucky Libraries Special Collections Research Center